Robinhoodโs performance as a public company has been less than stellar. The company went public in late July at an opening price of about $35 a share, and as of Fridayโs market close the stock was below $16.

There are multiple reasons for that decline; after all, the second half of 2021 was unkind to many publicly traded fintech companies. But surely some of the crappy performance is specific to Robinhood. Investors seem increasingly aware that the unprofitable Robinhoodโwhich jolted the brokerage world a few years ago by introducing commission-free tradesโno longer has much that is unique to offer its existing and potential customers.
For example:ย Acornsย is a well-funded fintech aimed at helping customers (including kids) bank intelligently and invest spare change. This week, the company introduced a new service that will allow customers to invest directly in stocks, as opposed to only in exchange-traded funds chosen by Acorns. This move wasย widely interpreted as a play for some of Robinhoodโs business/customer base. Given Acornsโ claimed 8.2 million customer baseโa little more than a third of Robinhoodโs claimed 22 millionโthatโs not the longest shot. Robinhood stock (in what was a pretty tough equities market week in general) dropped more than 7% on Thursday, seemingly in reactionโalthough it mostly recovered. Without more innovation from Robinhood, though, threats like this will continue to crop up.
A second problem has been Robinhoodโs corporate governance. There isnโt enough room in a normal-sized FIN item to include all the examples of the firmโs incompetence, but hereโs a quick summary:
- In December 2020,ย the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) fined Robinhood $65 millionย for making โfalse and misleading statementsโ about its use of payment for order flow.
- When theย GameStop Gรถtterdรคmerung hit in January 2021, Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev repeatedly said that โthere was no liquidity problemโ that forced the company to halt trading on its app. Within hours, it was revealed that the company couldnโt keep up with the deposit requirements of its clearinghouseโthe very definition of a liquidity problemโand had to scramble to raise billions from its investors.ย As FIN wrote a year ago, โa CEO who canโt tell the truth is a bigger issue than the inability to meet a margin call.โ
- The FINRA reportย (and accompanying $70 million fine) issued in late June catalogued multiple governance outrages, from technology breakdowns to a failure to report customer complaints to allowing teenagers to trade options.
Robinhood has taken some steps to provide at least the appearance of a properly run company. One thing we learned when the company went public is that the companyโs highest compensated employee is chief legal officerย Daniel Gallagher, a former Obama-appointed commissioner on the Securities and Exchange Commission.
But the stockโs continued illness suggests that stronger medicine is necessary. In public, venture capital firms like to tout the genius and dedication of the founders whom they fund, but behind the scenes there can be tremendous pressure on CEOs perceived as underperforming or otherwise screwing up.
Reading between the lines, that institutional discontent seems to be the impetus behindย this weekโs announcement that industry veteran Steve Quirk has been hiredย to fill a newly created Robinhood position of โchief brokerage officer.โ (Curiously, as of Sunday morning, Quirk had yet to updateย his LinkedIn pageย with his Robinhood gig.) Quirk is the textbook โsafe pair of handsโ: he served more than 14 years at TD Ameritrade. One of Quirkโs duties was to oversee active traders, which was especially important after the Great Recession as more investors began to take up option tradingโan obviously relevant credential for working at Robinhood. It will take more than an adult-in-the-room hire for Robinhood to turn itself around, but at least in the short run it may slow the stockโs downward slide.
The Digital Yuan Preps For Its Closeup
The world has been hearing more and more lately aboutย โsportswashing,โย in which unsavory regimes try to burnish their reputations by sponsoring prominent athletic teams or hosting prestigious tournaments. The upcoming Beijing Winter Olympics is a prime example, but FIN wonders if part of Chinaโs attempt to deflect from its human rights violations and aggressive territorial will involve showing off the progress of the digital yuan, which is by almost any yardstick already the worldโs most established central bank digital currency (CBDC).
The mainstreaming of the digital yuan has been underreported in the West. Consider that JD.com already offers digital yuan payment options, and this week WeChat Pay said it would add the same. For Americans this would be roughly the equivalent of PayPal, Amazon and Walmart all offering payment via CBDC. This week, the Chinese government made the digital yuan wallet available in the Apple and Android stores for users in 10 Chinese cities. It remains to be seen how the Peopleโs Bank of China will handle its relationship with big players like Tencent, but for now the digital yuan looks like it is going for the gold.
This piece originally appeared in FIN, James Ledbetterโs fintech newsletter. Ledbetter is Chief Content Officer of Clarim Media, which owns Techonomy.