From Elon Musk to Mark Zuckerberg, the titans of tech today have more notoriety than movie stars of yore and, often, the egos to match. But at what point does idolatryโwithin the culture of tech and beyond itโand internal self-regard get in the way of progress rather than bolster it?
This was the subject of Techonomy founder David Kirkpatrickโs conversation with Autodesk CEO Andrew Anagnost at Techonomy 22, which took place November 13-15 at the Fairmont Sonoma Mission Inn & Spa.
Within moments of welcoming Anagnost to the stage, Kirkpatrick dove right in. โDo you think tech has an ego problem?โ
โI do,โ replied Anagnost, who used the phrase โcelebrity technologistโ to characterize leaders known as much for their personalities as innovationsโand who may prioritize image over achievements. โI think itโs becoming a real danger right now. Because when you start ending up with ego driven initiativesโthings that are meant to achieve notoriety, be accepted in the cool crowdโpeople start pursuing results at all costs. Which leads to people not thinking about the consequences on the end user. It also leads to get-rich-quick schemes.โ
Kirkpatrick and Anagnost cited Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of crypto exchange FTX who was arrested on fraud charges in December, as an example of such perils.
โNow, you might say, โWait a second, we had Steve Jobs,โโ Anagnost continued, returning to the more general topic. โThere’s tons of big egos in tech. But it’s very different now.โ
โIs the thing you think that made it different just the sheer amount of money that got involved?โ Kirkpatrick asked.
Anagnost replied that it was two things. Yes, โThe velocity at which you can make money, which attracts a lot of people that aren’t necessarily passionate about tech but about the cash register.โ But what makes it more concerning is the impact tech breakthroughs can now haveโthe speed with which an innovation can be created and the breadth of society it can affect. Anagnost pointed out that in the early days of, say, Apple, power wasnโt as aggregated in specific niches. โPersonal computers at that time were touching a small smidgen of the economy. Today if you want to get notoriety in tech you’ve got to take down 10% of the economy.โ
Kirkpatrick laughed, ruefully. Then he pivoted to the subject of multibillion-dollar software company Autodesk, where Anagnost puts his ideas into action. Autodesk, a leader in 3D design and make technology, counts New Yorkโs One World Trade Center and many of Avatarโs visual effects among projects built with its software.
Anagnost said changes in the cloud and artificial intelligence are two factors turbo-charging innovation in his sector. โThe challenge here is that we could go whole hog on automation in the cloud [for example] and actually undermine an entire industry.โ
โAs a matter of fact,โ he continued, โsome of our customers are afraid that we’reโฆgoing to suddenly be able to automatically crank out a design for a building and dis-intermediate a whole segment of the market.โ
Even if and when such things come to fruition, Anagnost said, he believes in the idea of proceeding carefully. โI think the ethosโthat is often an ego driven ethosโis โLetโs cram the disruption through.โ I love disruptionโฆBut. This notion that thatโs the only way you can make that happen, Iโd like to challenge thatโฆHas it really created a path to getting things done or has it created a lot of mistakes that people had to circle back and fix?โ
Kirkpatrick asked for details on an alternative approach. โHow do you run Autodesk differently because you worry about these things?โ
โWe actually try to think through the disruptions weโre going to create. Iโll call it, perhaps tritely, having empathy for the people that are going to get disrupted by some of these technologies,โ Anagnost responded. โItโs not like weโre not going to do it. No, we’re going to do it. But we ask ourselves, โHow do we mitigate the impact?โโฆ And we try to invest in the ecosystem ahead of the impact.โ
Kirkpatrick turned to Anagnostโs interest in job creation and particularly his work to make sure lower paid positions, which are vulnerable to being outmoded by tech advances, can be replaced with other opportunities.
Anagnost nodded. โWe have spent a lot of time trying to invest in especially community college level education, which is going to be a critical feeder of some of the skill-sets that people are going to need to thrive in the new technologies.โ
With that, Kirkpatrick opened the conversation to audience questions. A woman raised her hand.
โI think that the Four Horsemen of technology are what I call โthe four F wordsโ,โ she said. โFear, fame, fortune, and fanaticism.โ
Anagnost cracked up.
โHow do you make the other sideโthe empathy, the forethought, the look at the impactsโhow do you motivate [people to subscribe to those things instead]?โ she asked.
Anagnost, serious again, told her itโs surprisingly straightforward. โThe way I figured this out in my career is that, you know what? Time to impact actually goes up if you do this a little bit more collaboratively… If you want to build to last, and I like to build to last, then you want to be a little bit more empathetic and humble.โ