The ideas are flowing fast, as is the money. Young (and old) the world over are increasingly drawn to entrepreneurship, and inventive tech solutions are emerging everywhere. Is โSilicon Valleyโ a spirit rather than a place? What makes a city attractive for company incubation? Is this energy likely to continue, or will cities like Detroit have trouble sustaining it? Will the successful companies of the future stay put or move elsewhere?
Kirkpatrick: So for our final session, you know, weโve been hearing today a lot about cities and weโve been hearing a lot about startups, and they do have a lot to do with each other, so weโre going to directly address that in this last session, and particularly how cities like Las Vegas and Detroit are making concrete efforts that are quite differentiated from whatโs happening elsewhere, to really take that integration and use it to boost both parties.
So Andrew Keen, the inimitable, will moderate this session, and please, Andrew, bring your panelists out.
Keen: So, I hope weโll bring everything together. Letโs start, you might introduce yourselves, and then just tell me one thing youโve learned today.
Yang: Hello all, Iโm Andrew Yang, Iโm the founder and CEO of Venture for America. Weโre a national non-profit organization that recruits top college graduates from around the country to work at startups here in Detroit, among other places. One of the things I learned today is that there are large shifts going on in the economy and society right now, and there are a bunch of institutions that need to adapt to it, and then there are other organizations that are just springing up from the ground to address those needs, and hopefully that those two sets of organizations can come together, somehow in the next day.
Linkner: Hi, good afternoon. Iโm Josh Linkner, Iโm the CEO and Managing Director of Detroit Venture Partners. Quick background is Iโve been an entrepreneur myself four timesโstarted, built and sold four tech companiesโand also the author of two books on innovation and creativity. And one thing I would say, not necessarily learned, but really reinforced today, is the need for continuous change. I mean, for any of us to say that weโve cracked the code to success or what weโre doing is going to work indefinitely is obviously a futile approach, and I think the idea of continuously reinventing ourselves, our organizations, and our community is the only real recipe for long-term and sustainable success.
Yang: I read Joshโs second book, it was very good.
Keen: So I wanted to introduce Jill, but before, maybe weโve got this, you know, Clay Christensen has this whole theory of the innovatorโs dilemma, of any company being a prisoner of its own innovation, we might develop that theory for cities, that every city alsoโand certainly that would include Silicon Valley and Detroitโhas its own innovation dilemma, that once it gets ahead, it gets behind.
Andy said that the future, all of our futures, is Detroit, so Jill, youโre from Detroit. Is that fair? What do you do, and is Detroit in all of our futures?
Ford: All roads lead to Detroit. So I am new here. I came here from the San Francisco Bay Area, and I am the Special Advisor to Mayor Mike Duggin, helping to figure out how we can revitalize the economy here through entrepreneurship. Iโm very excited about all the different supports that we can provide for innovation and entrepreneurship in Detroit, and one of the things that really stood out today is the value that comes from just bringing people together and having a conversation about great ideas, and then taking the actions to actually bring these things to life. And I love that weโre making a lot of these things happen in Detroit.
Keen: So what did you learn today?
Ford: Thatโs what I learned today, really, understanding the value of bringing people together and having those kinds of conversations.
Keen: You didnโt know that before?
Ford: Oh, I think it was a validation, kind of to what Josh was saying. So, I really enjoyed the validation of it. I think there were so many great things individually that I donโt want to just focus on any one particular one. I think the value is really in having those conversations and taking actions on them, and Iโm very happy aboutโ
Keen: And did you have a, were you born in Detroit, or you just came here from San Francisco?
Ford: I just came here from San Francisco, so Iโm a new person in town.
Keen: And thatโs intriguing that they would need to bring in an outsider from San Francisco as their sort of technology advisor.
Ford: Actually I was attracted to Detroit.
Keen: Why?
Ford: I heard about what was going on and I just saw an amazing opportunity here. I saw a set of challenges and a set of the ingredients that really, put together the right way, could create an amazing amount of social impact and revenue impact, and just really change the world, starting from Detroit.
Keen: Andy, is that true of everywhere? Youโre from the VegasTechFund, so youโre, I guess in a sense, the equivalent to Josh in Las Vegas. Is every city full of potential or does every city have its own unique potential?
White: Absolutely.
Keen: Well, which?
White: Whatโs that.
Keen: Which? I mean, itโsโ
White: We have the potential in every city, and a common thread throughout many of the conversations today is the understanding that weโre really just talking about building business and growing our communities. And yes, technology is enabling more and more of that, which means the change is accelerating, but this difference between a tech ecosystem or an innovation center or a startup community is a moot point, once itโs everywhere. And thatโs where we have the access to the resources. Itโs happening. And if itโs not happening in your community, then itโs probably going in the other direction.
Keen: This is the big question to me, and Andrew brings it up in his book, are these innovation communities zero-sum games? In other words, for Detroit to win or Pittsburgh to win, does it mean that, you know, Charlottesville or New Orleans have to lose, or can we all win? Is this really asโas Davidโs first thingโis this really the American Dream, which was about everybody winning, which, it isnโt a zero-sum game?
Yang: Well, certainly on the innovation front, every region has its own distinct advantages and strengths that they can build on. So thereโs a companyโI live in New York City, and New York City startups tend to revolve around finance and media, like, FinTech and AdTech or fashion, or something else that New Yorkโs really strong at. If you go to Baltimore it becomes health, biotech, cybertech. Here in Detroit, itโs a whole different set of strengths.
Keen: For example? What would those be, Josh? The particular strengths here?
Linkner: Well, I mean, we have a lot of things going on. In our case, weโre finding tech companies, thereโs obviously advanced manufacturing, thereโs alternative energy, thereโs a number of things. But to your earlier question, I donโt think itโs a zero-sum game. In the old economy it was. If I sold a bottle of water to you, you give me a dollar, I hand you this bottle of water, Iโm out one bottle of water, and youโre out one dollar. On the other hand, if I create a piece of art, which is the equivalent of innovationโor a new company out of nowhereโand I sell you my painting, you know, Iโve created something out of my head. Iโm not out of anything, and we both win in that sense.
Keen: But there is only a limited amount of venture money, and as Andrew says in his book, talent, I mean, it canโt be everywhere, right?
Linkner: Totally disagree. Totally disagree. I mean, there are talented people here in Detroit, way more than people think. And Iโm sure there are in Charlottesville and other places. I think itโs harnessing them and creating an environment thatโs supportive and helps probe the artistic sense of entrepreneurs to get them going, providing a safe environment and giving them the resources they need, but I donโt think thereโs a shortage of ideas and talent.
Yang: Since youโre citing my book, I just want to make sure.
The theme of Venture for America and my book is about what Josh is saying, which is trying to activate more of our talent, and Iโm certainly driven by this certainty that thereโs so much underutilized human intellectual capital out there. And I was in a corporate law firm in New York, which is like a temple to the squandering of intellectual capital.
So if we can just unlock more of that energy and creativity, then the skyโs the limit.
Keen: Jill, what has to happen in Detroit? What do we have toโwhat are you in the business of unlocking, and how do you do it? Whatโs the key, using the unlocking metaphor?
Ford: Well, I think there are different locks and different keys that we have to bring in. I really appreciated Joshโs comment about really the level of cross-collaboration that can bring great assets to Detroit, and then also help the other cities outside of Detroit to see the great assets that we have coming from Detroit. And so having that kind of interactive traffic and cross-pollination thatโs happening across cities, and giving us the opportunity to really have cross-collaborative partnerships, so that we can take advantage of how small the world is becoming, is an essential part of the success.
Keen: Give me an example of one of those partnerships with another city. How does that work?
Ford: Well, you can even think just distribution partnerships. So you can have a company that is based in one place but has customers globally, and so that kind of interaction then extends beyond just a closed system and really allows us to take advantage of all of the possibilities that we have in the world right now.
Keen: Andy, what advice would you give this mostly Detroit audience of entrepreneurs about the Vegas experience?
White: So we have some similar paths. I think the timingโs off a bit, and then of course we have a different set of resources to take advantage of, but the key is to identify those resources and to work together to redefine what it means to be a part of that community. Detroit has the unique distinction of having been the former, in whatever type of latter youโre looking at. This was the place. You can look all around you at the amazing buildings and the museums and the university and everything thatโs hereโthis was where it was all happening, and there are other places where thatโs now happening. Itโs going to happen again, and itโs going to happen much more rapidly.
Very few cities are going to have an opportunity to create an industry that will survive for over a century, and we have to plan for that. Youโre looking at 20, maybe 30 years that youโll have in any one sector, and it will be the surrounding sectors and the next thing that will continue to drive that. And itโs going to accelerate faster than any of us can imagine. So the sooner we realize that we donโt know that, and thatโs okay, and that the most important thing we can do is to prioritize learning over trying to execute on some answer we think we have, then those are the communities that will be able to really accelerate this change in the future.
Keen: So yours is a sort of theory of permanent destruction and reinvention, and the cycles are becoming shorter and shorter, is thatโyou all agree with that?
Yang: Yes.
Keen: So Jill, entrepreneurs donโt really need to worry about this, but city people do. What do you need to do? I mean, can you shore this thing up? Is it education? Is it bringing talent in? How do you try and guarantee that the next cycle will be 50 years versus 10?
Ford: I think that thereโs a role for each party to play in this, and no one party really does it by itself. A lot of this really comes from the amazing talent that we have in the people here. I mean, if you look at who is actually going out and starting the businesses and doing the investing and connecting and creating global customer basesโthis is happening from the people who are living in Detroit, and who are coming to Detroit. And so we want to invest in those people, invest in a whole variety of ways, to really enableโand as Josh was sayingโreally accelerate and activate the folks that we have here. And then also to make sure that weโre providing the right attractions for people to realize the opportunities that are here in Detroit, and to come and be a part of our community.
Linkner: Andrew you said two words I want to flip around, if I may. So you said, how can we make a cycle 50 years instead of 10 and how can we guarantee something for the future? Iโd say we shouldnโt do either of those things, personally. First of all, there are no guarantees, and I think we fell victim to the fact that while we were guaranteed a great futureโweโre the automotive capital of the worldโand that sense of entitlement was one of the main factors that hurt us. So I think we need to build a culture and a community that isnโt about guarantees. Weโre constantly adapting and changing, and thereโs no way our plan that we craft today will hold for 50 years. Secondly, instead of trying to take our cycle from 10 to 50, we should be thinking how do we take the cycle from 10 to 1? So we should get into the habit of adapting and changing and evolving at record speed, because thatโs what happening on the global stage, and if we start to think that, โHey, letโs build something thatโs going to lock it down for 50 years,โ weโre going to be in the same mess that we were 10, 15 years ago here in Detroit.
Keen: But youโve still got to try and make your place successful. I mean, one of the panels today, somebody from Indiegogo was boasting that as a seven-year-old her parents didnโt give her money, they forced her to become entrepreneurial. Is that a beginning? Do we begin in the family? Do we want to make all our kids into entrepreneurs in this sort of entrepreneurial/reputation economy?
Yang: So, Iโm something of a new parent. I have a two-year-old.
Keen: Well, I hope youโre giving them money. Are you? Theyโre out there foraging in the streets of New York.
Yang: I heard Danaeโs story and I said, โWow, thatโs incredible, I need to remember that for five years from now.โ
Keen: Why?
Yang: Because itโs incredible training that I certainly didnโt get.
Keen: For a seven-year-old?
Yang: I mean, it worked. Sheโs on the stage, and sheโs co-founded an incredible company. I mean, Iโd certainly roll the dice on that outcome more than, โHey, hunker down and do what youโre told and everythingโs going to work out.โ So I think itโs family, I think itโs education, I think itโs our institutions. Like, we all have toโlike Jillโs sayingโthere are so many pieces to this puzzle that every individual institution has to try and migrate in that general direction in order for us to be able to, as a society and an economy, be able to approach the future in a way thatโsโ
Keen: Well, you were telling the story backstageโyou donโt have to mention namesโbut this is sort of still a very conservative culture, where parents are putting pressure on their kids to become lawyers or doctors, and you feel that thatโs very counterproductive.
Yang: So I read an article a while ago about what did Greek parents want their children to do? They wanted them to become lawyers and doctors, and then when the bottom fell out of that economy, you ended up with a bunch of lawyers without clients and doctors who couldnโt get paid. So itโs not a great way to try andโright now, certainly, the educational culture in this country emphasizes stable paths, professional roots, so itโs law schoolโwhich I didโmed school, investment banking, management, consulting. And these professional servicesโlike academia, you could throw in thereโthis professional services layer exists sort of atop growth businesses, and after a business gets to a certain point then you need to hire a lawyer, you need to hire an accountant, you need to hireโand so if you invest talent in building the services layer, you end up having icing without a cake, over time. You end up with like layers and layers of icing, and then youโre like, hey, you know, youโre looking for something thatโ
Keen: But Joshโyouโre a successful entrepreneur. Can that be taught? I mean, were you born as an entrepreneur? Why did you become one?
Linkner: I actually do believe it can be taught. I mean, Andrew and I were talking about this earlier. Itโs very difficult to build a company, you know, thereโs all these different skills that you need, from finance and insight and people, and all that stuff. But I do believe that the core of it can be taught, in the same way that jazz music can be taught.
So I originally was a jazz musician. That was my first career. And I would argue that jazz musicians are no more creative than the next person, but the culture of a jazz combo facilitates you to take responsible risks. In other words, if we were all playing jazz together, and I played it safe, Iโd get laughed off the stage. On the other hand, if I played a wrong note, Iโd play it twice more and weโd call it art, and everyone would be happy.
So the culture of a jazz combo facilitates people to take responsible risks, to go for it, to be innovative, to be creative, and that is actually a teachable skill, and itโs identical to the skills that are needed for entrepreneurship.
Keen: Jill, is that what youโd like Detroit to become? A city of entrepreneurs? A city full ofโnot everyone, of course, can be Joshโbut a city of people who are willing to take risks? Is that the goal when you advise the mayor? Do you think that thatโs a noble ambition of a city?
Ford: One of the things that Iโve learned since coming to Detroit is that Detroit is already a city of entrepreneurs. There are entrepreneurs of all kinds here. I mean, everything from the person who is selling cheesecakes at her church on Sunday, to the people who are doing tech companies in some of our co-working spaces, to some of the more manufacturing-related businesses. I mean, we have a whole variety, and I think one of the things thatโ
Keen: But I donโt mean to pick on you here, but is thatโis someone who sells cheesecake at a churchโtheyโre not an entrepreneur; entrepreneurs take risks. Isnโt a risk, an entrepreneur is someone whoโsโthatโs maybe a way of making a little bit of money, but is itโI mean, I donโt know how the rest of you define an entrepreneurโ
Linkner: I would say that an entrepreneur doesnโt have to be a tech startup guy in a hoodie. Thatโ
Keen: No, I accept that.
Linkner: But I think as someone who worksโ
Keen: But you have to take some risk, rather than just selling cheesecake or lemonade on the street.
Linkner: Maybe entrepreneurs are people that change things. Theyโre provocateurs, they look at things, what can be, instead of just what is. So I think you can be entrepreneurial even if you work at a large company. I donโt think you have to start a company to be an entrepreneur.
Yang: Yeah, I would feel very bad if no one bought my cheesecake and I was sitting at that table. I mean, thatโs a risk, isnโt it?
Ford: Exactly. I completely agree and I think that one of the mistakes we could make is if we donโt see entrepreneurship in all of these different kinds of places. Entrepreneurship starts with ideas, it starts withโas you were sayingโbeing willing to take risks, it starts with taking action on these ideas, and so thatโs happening in all kinds of different ways, and we embrace that and then start to help people understand how they can really accelerate that. So to go from selling the cheesecake at church to selling the cheesecakes at many churches, to selling them on the webโthatโs how businesses start, from an idea and then grow into something that can beโ
Keen: And thatโs happening in Detroit more than other cities, or is it just a typical city in that sense?
White: Part of the breakdown of education is positive in that way. Can we train you to be an entrepreneur is a wrong question. Itโs why do we spend so many resources training people not to be? You donโt look at a two-year-old and go, โAw, thatโs going to be a great worker. I canโt wait until they get into a structured environment where they can start being productive.โ Theyโre invincible. They go out and try everything. Thatโs the entrepreneurial spirit. And then we take them through this system that then extracts every bit of that to where we get to the point where weโre now adults and weโre not allowed to do those things anymore. And thatโs what weโre looking at.
Ford: Right. Also you asked the question of, can entrepreneurship be taught? We have to make sure that weโre not un-teaching it from our young people. We have to make sure that weโre encouraging them to be willing to embrace new ideas and try things, and those are really the seeds that then will become some of our greater businesses.
Keen: What about the people who canโt become entrepreneurs? What happens to them?
Yang: So this may be not on-theme, but I think that most people probably should not try and start their own businesses. I think that doing that is extraordinarily difficult, it is fraught with risk toโ
Keen: Even selling the cheesecake?
Yang: Yeah, some people might not be able to handle not having their cheesecake be bought. No, I mean, everyone should sell a cheesecake, clearly, but, but starting a business is not for everyone, so if itโs not for you, to me, thatโs totally acceptable. You should not think to yourself, like, โOh, you know, Iโm deficient somehow because Iโm not set to start a company.โ I think that there are incredible ways to be enterprising within a large organization. There are ways of finding an entrepreneur and supporting him or her in the growth of their enterprise, which every quality entrepreneur, Josh, everyone can speak to this, itโs not one person. Itโs always a whole team of people pulling together to help get that enterprise to become EPrize or Zappos or whatever it happens to be.
So if youโre interested in entrepreneurship, try and join a team. I mean, thatโs really what we talk about at Venture for America. Itโs like, itโs not all the founder story, because if we were all founders, that would be a really bizarre way to try and build an economy, you know what I mean? Weโd all be like, hey, you want my thing? I want your thing? It would be crazy.
Keen: Do you agree?
White: Again, I look at the opposite side of it. Itโs not what is an entrepreneur so much as what isnโt an entrepreneur. And so to not be one means that youโve been trained, and you know the answer, and youโre going to execute, and youโre never going to try and find a better way to do it. And so anyone that takes just the littlest amount of effort to try and find a better way, or to look at things in a different light, or improve the process, thatโs part of the entrepreneurial spirit, and yes, everyone has that in them and everyone should be utilizing that in what theyโre doing. We will all be much better off if thatโs happening on a consistent basis.
Linkner: I think if we get back to the definition, is an entrepreneur necessarily a founder of a company? And I think those are really two different things. I mean, I look at the great work Jill is doing, and sheโs working in the public sector, but I absolutely think sheโs an entrepreneur, because sheโs shaking things up here in Detroit and making a real difference and an impact, so to me, entrepreneurship, the act of doing that is something that is very inclusive that all of us, hopefully, are tapping into.
And if weโre not, thatโs how regret gets formed. No one wants to look back 30, 40 years from now and say, oh, these are all the risks I didnโt take. This is all the difference I wasnโt able to impact. I think each of us, in our own way, can be entrepreneurial, whether we start a company or not.
Keen: So if we could capture this thing in a bottle, is it about rebelling, not accepting the way things are, challenging.
White: We call it prioritizing learning over being right, and in our education systemโ
Keen: I donโt understand. What does that mean?
White: Weโve been taught that you study for the test, you get the answer, when youโve put the correct answer on the paper, then thatโs success. And then you get out in the real world and you find out thatโs not always success. Success can mean that things have changed and you need to adapt in order to be successful, and thatโs what we need to prioritize, is that ability to learn from that and adapt, and make sure weโre applying that to the next scenario.
Keen: I always feel that when we have these kind of panels about innovation and people get round to saying itโs an educational problem, or an educational issue, theyโre kind of acknowledging that they donโt have the solution.
White: I donโt think thatโs the case.
Keen: The education system is in crisis in this country, but we always seem to be coming back to education.
Yang: So I went to law school, not a very entrepreneurial thingโ
Keen: But it is pretty entrepreneurial, isnโt it?
Yang: It is 100% not.
Keen: What does that mean? Why?
Yang: Itโsโ
Keen: You mean itโs like rote learning?
Yang: I mean, thereโs a lot of it. Itโs prettyโyouโre studying, like, 100-year-old cases. Itโs like the opposite of the future.
Keen: So entrepreneurs shouldnโt go to law school?
Yang: I would not recommend it. So I left to start a company. It was my first time really doing anythingโI was not the Asian kid selling lemonade or anything like thatโto start a company in my mid-20s, crashed and burned, lost investorsโ hundreds of thousands, and found entrepreneurship was excruciatingly hard. It was so hard that I could not pull it off.
So then I said, โOkay, how do you get better at this thing?โ And the way I got better is I followed someone like Josh around for four years, and started to think a little bit more the way they thought, and then eventually got to a point where I was able to contribute some value, ended up running an education company that was acquired by the Washington Post.
So I have strong feelings about this, because you say, hey, fix education, that will result in entrepreneurship. You learn to be an entrepreneur the way you learn most things, which is you find someone whoโs really good at it, and then you become his or her sidekick for X period of time. Some people who are fortunate grow up in that environment, like, if your family runs a business then you get it from that. Some people, like, somewhere might go to some school that teaches them thatโthough Iโve seen this schoolโand other people like me just go through the school of hard knocks, then find a more experienced entrepreneur, like Joshโand so what Josh has done here in Detroit is phenomenal. It says Josh is a vet entrepreneur. So heโs like spread his wings, and said, hey, aspiring entrepreneurs, come under my wings, itโs warm, itโs toasty. And thatโs what we need.
Keen: So Josh, did you have a model for what you did? Like a Silicon Valley model, or you just made it up like jazz music as you go along?
Linkner: In my case, I was jazz music all along, but I think thereโs probably a much more effective way. I mean, I made so many mistakes, scraped up my knees, you know, lostโbut you learn itโyouโre exactly right, I think itโs on the job learning, and I donโt think itโI mean, thereโs a lot of challenges with the educational system, but what can we do now that weโre out of the educational system? I think weโve got to get into the fight and start going.
Keen: Jill, we had a panel earlier about diversity in the workplace, and the issue of mentorship came up. How important is it in a town like Detroit, that you have a mentor like Josh?
Ford: I think itโs not just important in Detroit. I think mentorship is important globally. As weโve all talked about, itโs very important to have an opportunity to learn, and sometimes you donโt know what you donโt know, and so being able to find somebody whoโs more experienced than you can really help to open your eyes to new possibilities.
Keen: And Josh when someone comes under your warm wing, what do you try and teach them? I mean, when someone follows you around, what do you think they learn from you that they wouldnโt learn from going to university or reading a book about entrepreneurship.
Linkner: First of all, just to be clear, there are lots of paths to entrepreneurship. Iโm a bit embarrassed with this whole wing analogy. What I can say, what we do is we provide capital to our entrepreneurs, but we also, we think that capital is one of many ingredients that are necessary for startup success. So we are also coaching, mentoring, I meanโI spend my days not poring over spreadsheets, weโre role-playing an important sales meeting before it happens, or weโre dealing with a tough HR issue together, or weโre figuring out how do we continuously adapt in a radically changing environment. So I think itโs really like Andrew says, being in the trenches more than it is an academic study.
Keen: Jill, how important is it for an event like Techonomy to come to Detroit? Does it sort of confirm what youโre doing, or is it the trigger for innovation?
Ford: I love the idea of having events like Techonomy come to Detroit. I think that anytime we have such a diverse mix of people and ideas and experiences, it just creates fertile ground for innovation.
Keen: Certainly, I think, itโs a veryโI mean, I havenโt been here before. Itโs a very good decision of David and his team to bring Techonomy here. How, in terms of Las Vegas, what else do you think you can teach Detroit? Or what can you learn from Detroit?
White: Yeah, I think thatโs the key. Since this is the way that weโre building business and growing our communities, we all have things to learn from each other. There certain aspects of it that weโve been successful at, that weโre excited about, that we like to tout. People in other areas look at that and go, wow, thatโs amazing that youโve done that much in short amount of time. But then on the third side, we know all the things that didnโt work with that and all the things we still have to do, so we always underappreciate what weโve done, even though we talk about it. The others over-appreciate it, because theyโre just seeing the end result, and what we need to be doing is really talking about what helped us get there, and how we can evolve that process.
Itโs important to have a process and to make sure we can replicate, but then build into that the flexibility, and thatโs what weโre seeing here.
Keen: Does size matter?
White: It depends on who you ask.
Keen: Well, let me ask you. The lady who gave us the tour of Detroit yesterday said Detroit was an optimal size, it was biggerโI think, without wishing to misquote, it was big enough to matter but small enough that you could make a difference. Is that right? So, does size matter? Is it the right size? I mean, Iโm sure there are people in the audience from smaller towns than Detroit and larger towns, and weโre all trying to figure out the same thing. How to emulate Detroit, how to beat Detroit, how to set up innovation centers, because clearly thatโs the future for every city.
Linkner: I think we are an optimal size, frankly. You said big enough to matter and small enough to make a difference. We have the necessary ingredients here. We have talent, we have capital, we have a great airport, I meanโyou name it, weโve got the right ingredients. We have to get out of our shell and be willing to take some more risks than we have in the past, but I think we have real advantages.
Keen: So you havenโt taken enough risks in the past?
Linkner: No.
Keen: Youโre still in your shell? Youโre not in a shell. Youโre under wing.
Linkner: I think, you know, itโs amazing when you watch the cycle. 100 years ago, when we were the Silicon Valley of our country, we took fabulous risks.
Keen: Is that true? Or is that just the clichรฉ, that you were the Silicon Valley of America?
Linkner: Well they were the Detroit of the West Coast, really. We were the source of innovation. This is where people came to build their fortunes, were very entrepreneurial. Then we stopped doing that. We stopped creating, we became veryโ
Keen: When did you stop? 1930? 1940?
Linkner: Something like that. And we ran the opposite playbook and we suffered greatly. And now weโre once again reconnecting to those entrepreneurial roots and really taking off. But I think itโs important as we look at this transformationโwe shouldnโt be replicating what happened in San Francisco or Boston or New York; we need to be authentic to who we areโbut the opportunity here is profound, and I really believe that weโre going to be studying this period for decades to come as this incredibly transformative period where entrepreneurship and innovation was rekindled and ultimately made a huge difference.
Keen: Do you mean you have to get to the bottom to be able to come up again? I mean, if Detroit hadnโt had the pretty awful experiences of the last 15 or 20 years, would it have been possible to have the kind of rejuvenation and innovation youโre now experiencing?
White: Possible, yes. Challenging, incredibly. You donโt think in this way when things are going good, and thatโs definitely a lesson learned in Vegas, and one of our concerns coming out of this, is weโve come out of the downturn so rapidly now that we may not have learned all the lessons we need to. And so itโs going to be that much easier to fall back into these old habits that got us right to where we started.
Linkner: Andrew, you said something earlier I just want to touch on. You said about 95% of startups fail, and just real quickly, because Iโve been involved in about 100 startup launches. The two things I see that make startups fail is not lack of vision, itโs lack of execution. Itโs just sort of good, old fashioned holding people accountable, marching things down the field, adapting, you know. The hard work of building a business.
And the second reason I think entrepreneurs tend to fail is they say, well this is going to be great because Iโm the boss, and Iโm going to boss people around and great leaders are servants, theyโre not kings, and great leaders job is to serve those around them, whether itโs their customers or their team members. So when you take someone who is thinking of themselves as a servant-leader, combine that with an executionally focused leader, I think the startup statistics look much more favorable.
Keen: So youโre saying 95% donโt really fail?
Linkner: I think definitely not 95% of the people that look at the world that way donโt.
Keen: But are you in the school of failure-is-success school, that itโs good to fail? And Silicon Valley, one of the unique things about Silicon Valley is the more money someoneโs made, the more they claim to be a failure. Is this something we should boast about, that failure is a good things? I mean, did you ever fail? You failed as jazz musician, right?
Linkner: I still play from time to time. I failed hundreds and hundreds of times. It depends what you define as failure. Iโve never cratered a company and lost everything, but I think that the people that win the most also fail the most, because they donโt look at failure as this all or nothing binary outcome, they say, โHey, this particular experiment didnโt work, how can I learn, adapt and grow, and make the next one more effective?โ
Keen: My own experience, by the way, is the more you fail, the more you seem to go up in the world.
Linkner: Totally agree.
Keen: That was a joke, but go on.
White: The failure point just means that you waited too long to learn, because if youโre learning along the way, you donโt call it a failure; it wasโthatโs how you innovate out of it.
Keen: But Jill, for theโweโve got some young people here, and I know weโve got some questionsโyou know, itโs all very well for us to joke about failure, but you know, for a 20-year-old kid, you know, whether or not theyโre selling the cheesecake or doing a startup, failure is very, very hard to deal with, isnโt it?
Ford: I think itโs all about your perspective. So as everyone has mentioned here, failure can be a learning opportunity, and for people who see it as such, it wouldnโt be quite aโ
Keen: But thatโs just sort of an academicโif youโre going through itโ
Yang: When my company went under, it felt like the end of the world. I remember looking up at the ceiling, wondering how I was ever going to recover, my net worth was negative $100,000 because I still owed law school debt, and the investors had lost everything. But then at some point, months later, you actually get it back, where you realizeโI remember thinking to myself, like, โOkay, whatโs really happening here?โ And like, if I met someone, they wouldnโt know that my net worth was negative $100,000, unless I was stupid enough to tell them, which I obviously would not. And that no one comes and takes your stuff, you can still go out, the sunโs still shining, like, your family will still spend time with you. So there are things thatโI never want to make light of failure, because now I wear a suit and Iโm onstage and itโs always ridiculousโitโs ridiculous in that itโs like, oh, itโs easy to talk about, like you said; itโs easy to talk about it after the factโbut I will say that getting through that process makes you a different type of person, where for years afterwards I was like, โWell, worst that could happen is this company could go under, and Iโve dealt with that before, so it canโt be that bad.โ And I would say that to myself for literally like six years afterward.
Keen: Well, I hope youโre getting your child to go out to work.
Yang: Heโs, yeah. Iโm going to hook him up with Zach later, heโs going to learn some coding, so.
Naumann: So my question isโa lot of what Iโve been hearing isโ
Keen: Why donโt you introduce yourself, too?
Naumann: Oh yeah, my name is Jason Naumann, with 3D Marketing Solutions, and my question, it relates to something you brought up earlier, Andrew, which has to do with is it a net zero-sum game? I think thereโs a limited amount of financial resources. I think itโs great to continue to foster communities of innovation, where people are continuing to push the boundaries and advance technology and advance our society, but does a culture of entrepreneurs require something that goes beyond our current financial system, maybe something more related to Blockchainโs system of exchanging goods or ideas for other goods and ideas? Thatโs, because for me it seems like thereโs only so much money you can get, and as long as weโre continuing to produce things that are going to benefit the corporations, the money is going to keep funneling to the corporations, or being slightly distributed to us for our innovations. Thanks.
Yang: So I run a non-profit, and Iโm happy to share that there is a lot of money out there that is not doing anything that awesome. You know what I mean? Like, there are things where, if you can get to the right peopleโthe limitation is not that thereโs not enough money in the world, especially with our current Fed Reserve scheme, which is essentially just to hit print and to just let it go. So, you know, I mean I believe in nonmonetary exchanges, weโve gotten a lot of stuff done through essentially like favors and other things, but I donโt think that a lack of capital is going to be the bottleneck.
Keen: But Josh, youโve only got a certain amount of money to invest. Youโre not limitless. You donโt print your own money, right? So I mean this zero-sumโthere is some truth, isnโt there? I mean, itโs not infinite opportunities.
Linkner: I think thereโs capital available for entrepreneurs who are great entrepreneurs with great ideas. I really do. Just like there are lots of actors in L.A. and then someone bubbles to the top and someone gets a movie deal. And so I think that itโs hard, itโs competitive, but when I started my companies, there was nowhere near the capital that was available here, and I had plenty of capital availability, because we were scrappy, we went out and figured it out. And I think today more than ever, I think entrepreneur capital is more accessible, and again, competitive, but itโs there when you need it.
Keen: Jill, do you think itโs good to have kind of too much money swirling around the system, or is it good to keep entrepreneurs hungry?
Ford: Well, Iโm sure people would ask the question, can you ever have too much money? But I think that thereโsโit takes more to succeed in a business than just capital. It takes relationships and people who are going to be behind you, to one of the earlier comments that we had. It takes great ideas and a continuation of those great ideas as you reach different potential inflection points for your business. So I really like that the question spoke about capital, but also spoke about some of the other things that you really need to grow a business, and I do think that the more we have people putting their passion and excitement behind businesses, and their time, that becomes an opportunity for investment.
Keen: Can we keep the questionsโI know thereโs a few, and itโs always nice to be the last panel because you donโt get into trouble if you go over, but Iโm sure people have other things to doโso if you can keep your questions short, and maybe we can ask a few and then we can get the panel to respond.
Mohammed: Mohammed from 242 Solutions. So weโve had a very interesting experience raising capital in Michigan, which we havenโt actually doneโI should say trying to. So we basically pitched to some of the leading venture capital companies and what weโve been told is that theโif we were to try to raise somewhere else, letโs say San Francisco, New York, somewhere else, that we would have a higher chance of actually raising money. Now most people say, well, hey you guys have generated some cash, you guys have a platform in a relatively short period of time, interesting market, and so that in many cases hasnโt actually resonated to the companies that weโve pitched here. We did actually pitch DVP, so including DVP. And the answer has been, you know, itโs notโit seems like itโs too risky or too early or something along those lines thatโs rooted in some sort of, itโs not as sexy of a market or the marketโs not that big, can you really sell this to that many customers.
And so the question is like, is it likely for that to actually be true, that raising money in other places would be easier because other places might be a little less risk-averse?
Keen: Thanks a lot. Letโs give them a couple more questions.
Audience 1: Mineโs more like a comment than a question, per se. This is issue about whether entrepreneurs are born, whether entrepreneurs are made or whether it can be taught, or what have you. I do think there has to be a certain aptitude for entrepreneurship. I can say that with some bona fides, because Iโve been one since 1976, and thereโs a point where the rubber meets the road. Like they say, some people are born to greatness, some people have greatness thrust upon them, and some people just stumble into greatness. Entrepreneurship comes about those same ways, in some respects, but there has to be a core attitude, there has to be a core aptitude, and you have to be very, very capable of taking risks. And when I say rubber meets the road, you separate the men from the boys, the women from the girls, when you have to make payroll.
Audience 2: My question has to do with actually something that was brought up during the American Dream session early on, and that has to do with any comments from you guys or ideas about how to bring entrepreneurship and have more people participate in it in communities where thatโs not normalized behavior, thatโs not an option or a possibility that people are thinking of.
Audience 3: I just really wanted to answer your question from before about is Detroit different, and I think that it is, because thereโs a lot of people that, because we didnโt have some of the thingsโthey just asked the question, why donโt we have this? And then followed that up with, okay, Iโll do it. And itโs kind of accidental entrepreneurs, or what I call โdoers.โ And then my question is so, Josh, you talked about the people that just want to be the boss, and thereโs a little bit of sexiness now attached to, โIโm going to be an entrepreneur,โ and they just hear that, and they have a great T-shirt idea, or this app, and they want to be that instant millionaire. How can you teach them? I mean, can they be saved from being that kind of person, and kind of actually become a leader-entrepreneur versus a pie-in-the-sky idea?
Keen: And all these questions sort of bring to me the idea of, you know, being an entrepreneur now is a life calling, itโs so meaningful, and you know, rejection is incredibly hardโand one entrepreneur seems to want to know the truth about why he isnโt getting funding. Are VCs telling him the truth, or are they just being polite? So your role is as much sort of spiritual as economic, now. Is that fair? I mean, this is like a church, this is like a movement.
Yang: To springboard on one of Joshโs earlier points, I sometimes joke that being an entrepreneur is like being a professional musician, which is, you should avoid it if you can.
Keen: So, if you can, but thereโs a calling? Sometimes you canโt avoid it?
Yang: It is like that. There are times whenโso I think in the best case, an entrepreneur wants to solve a problem. They just want to solve that problem real bad, and then they say, โIโm just not going to rest until I solve that problem.โ I mean, thatโs certainly been something Iโve experienced.
Keen: So it is a temptation for you, just couldnโt avoid?
Linkner: Absolutely. It draws youโif you chase it for the wrong reasons, if you chase it for money, fame, glory, whateverโyou very rarely will hit your target. If youโre doing it because thatโs your calling and you believe in it, thatโs what you were put on Earth to do, then youโre going to have a quick result.
I just want toโI can answer you really fast, your question. Itโs hard to find capital anywhere. Youโre going to get asked those same questions in Silicon Valley, Boston or New York. Is the market opportunity big enough? Is it scalable? All those things. Average in Silicon Valley, 1 out of 300 pitches gets funded, so Iโm not sure that itโs a geographic thing, and maybe either the way itโs being presented or the business model itselfโwhich by the way, maybe you could tweak and adapt, and have a great successโand your question also, how do you do it?
I think earlier what you said about mentorship is great. I think by surrounding yourself with people; maybe youโre not starting yourself but you find other mentors to help in that journey, I think those are skills too that absolutely can be learned.
Keen: Jill, youโre nodding.
Ford: Well, I want to piggyback off the mentorship thing, because there are mentors who are very physical, right near you, but you can also find a sort of virtual mentorship by finding people whose career paths you really admire, and just kind of learn more about what theyโve done and what made them successful and what were some of their failures along the way, and just really be able to learn fromโ
Keen: Should mentors be really honest, and if someone they donโt think had the real callingโif all they want to do is make money, or they just donโt really have the talent, should you be honest and tell people?
Yang: So this actually relates to the funding question, and I apologize if I made it seem like it was easy to get money, because itโs never easy to get money for profit, non-profit, neverโI was just commenting, like, macro. But nine times out of ten, thereโs a lot of things you can do that donโt involve money to move the enterprise forward, and thatโs like the stuff that is like the stuff that, when you talk about like, hey should I encourage or discourage this person? If the person is the right person, theyโre going to move forward regardless of whether or not I encourage or discourage them, you know? So like, and you should try and be honest and see who is going to make it happen, with or without the funding.
Keen: Well, honesty, final word, Andy, youโre looking sad.
White: Why thank you for noticing. So the other question that wasnโt addressed yet is how do you be an entrepreneur in a community that doesnโt focus on that right now? Every community started with entrepreneurship. We started this country by landing in one place, and now we cover the entire, this part of the continent. Every new group that decided to pick up and go somewhere else, that was a group of entrepreneurs. Every person that started a new business. And itโs all shifting. And one of our biggest gaps we have right now is there is still a mental barrier between the traditional investor and entrepreneur, who has built our cities to where they are today, and the tech entrepreneur and the tech investor, and the quicker we can bring those two things together, and decide that this is just about building business, and the better we work together to do that, then thatโs what will allow us to accelerate out of it. And that entrepreneurial spirit is at the core of every single community across the country.
Keen: Well, I think this was a great panel, because it didnโt have any simple solutions, no easy answers, but it did reflect the incredible complexity, and I think centrality of this challenge of being an entrepreneur in our innovation economy and Detroitโs fascinating place in it. So I want to thank you guys, fantastic panel.
Kirkpatrick: Thank you to the panel, and I would say that point that Andrew just madeโAndy, Andrew, Andrew and Andy, right?โis, thatโs what Techonomy is all about, trying to bridge those two worlds, and I think today was a great experiment in that. We continue to experiment, itโs entrepreneurship, three years of running the company, weโre still going.