What has philanthropy achieved in Detroit and Americaโs cities, and where will it go next? Join the heads of the Case and Kresge Foundations for a conversation on the role of foundations in the revival of urban life. How do they see their role in bolstering partnerships and collaboration in the communities they serve? How do they enable a new notion of civics, and civic leaders driven by the use of tech for social good?
Kirkpatrick: So the next session really is going to look at, in this age of metrics, there are aspects of city lifeโart and recreation, for exampleโthat are tangible but not quantifiable, and for some of these things, as public dollars dry up, private money is necessary. And thereโs two really incredible philanthropists about to join us onstage.
Once upon a time, Kresge Five-and-Dime stores were born right here in Detroit. That transmuted into K-Mart. The Kresge Foundation remains as a legacy of the great Kresge fortune thatโs been used for the betterment of Detroit and elsewhere, and so weโll hear them onstageโalong with Rip Rapson, from that organizationโalong with Jean Case, the CEO of the Case Foundation. And weโve hosted Jean before; weโre happy to have her back. And Detroit News editorial page editor Nolan Finley will moderate, so please welcome Rip, Jean and Nolan.
Finley:ย Detroitโs just red hot on the national stage, and itโs no better proof of that than having a technology conference in a city thatโs synonymous with manufacturing. It just shows how much things have changed and how fast Detroit is diversifying and growing. Weโre hereโwe donโt have a whole lot of time, so we need to get started, but you know, weโre here to talk about foundations and the new role of foundations in our communities and our major cities, and I guess, Rip, thereโs no better example in the country of a foundation that has transformed, and in the process helped transform its community, than the Kresge Foundation and what you all have done over the last several years here. And we were talking previously aboutโduring this great recession, the institutions of Detroit collapsed. The city government went into chaos. Our business community was struggling for its lives, and the foundations stepped up to play a new role, led by the Kresge Foundation. Would you talk about the new role that foundations are playing, and how that fits into the overall transformation of Detroit? Youโre not just writing checks anymore.
Rapson: Right. Well you know, Adlai Stevenson once said, itโs sort of hard to lead a cavalry charge if you think you look funny on a horse. I think for a long time, philanthropy felt it looked funny on a horse, and it really took this sort of convergence of the public sector really having its bottom fall out, with the indictment of a mayor, the recession, the foreclosure crisis, the autos and others sort of in their bunkers. And so in many ways, the philanthropic sector was the only sector left standing, and Iโd like to think it was in some ways prescient on our part to see that coming and kind of get prepared and geared up and enter the fray, but in many ways it took the severity of the crisis for us to kind of fully optimize our role. And I suspect Jean will talk about it, but itโs all about risk-taking. It really is about sort of putting a set of ideas on the table that perhaps are uncomfortable or unprecedented. Itโs peeling away risk out of deal structures, that the city desperately needs in order to survive. Itโs taking the risk of pulling multiple sectors together, because the private and the public and the non-profit sector all have to work together.
So my sense is what has happened in philanthropy in Detroit, is that weโve really sort of carved out a new role. And what Iโm hoping is that that doesnโt now go away, now that things seem to be stabilizing, that we really follow Jeanโs advice and sort of keep sort of leaning into these questions at the sharp edge of risk, because I think thatโs the only way that you sustain the kind of energy that you talked about.
Finley: Jean, Rip works for, represents a mature foundations, if you will.
Case: Right.
Finley: Youโre a relatively young foundation. Harder or easier for the newer foundations to do, than the sort of hide-bound institutions, like Kresge and like some of the others?
Case: You know, I think so, Nolan. Let me just start by saying itโs a pleasure to be onstage with these two gentlemen, and actually to be back in Detroit. We came out last year and participated in the conference, and I brought our entire team from the Case Foundation, and Rip and some other foundations hosted us here, and we had an opportunity to really see firsthand the exciting things taking place, and to learn and to understandโbut to your question, for those of you that donโt know the Case Foundation, we were born out of two tech careers, that my husband and I were privileged enough to have, in building a great company in AOL. And really, the idea that animated that companyโaccess to ideas, information, communicationโit was, of course, a very risk-tolerant environment in tech overall, and at that company, and we brought that same spirit to our foundation. So we are what they call living donors, which is a little different than some of the bigger established foundations, but we find that thereโs a tremendous space for us to learn together and learn from each other.
I think when itโs your own money that your deploying, the comfort level of taking risks with that money is different. I often say, you know, gosh, if you gave me $100 dollars that you have and asked me to take care of it for you or spend it in a certain way, Iโd suddenly turn pretty cautious, but when itโs my own $100 dollars, Iโm much more willing to take some risks with that. So some of the work that weโve been engaged in, that Rip referenced, is a campaign called Be Fearless, and the idea behind Be Fearless is really calling the sector more broadlyโand the sector weโll define not just as philanthropies, not just as non-profits, but the public sector too. That we live in a day when we need to innovate. Things are broken. Our communities need help, they need new solutions to old problems, and you canโt innovate without taking risks, and if youโre going to take risks, you risk failure. So we have to accept that failure is an option, it might happen, donโt let it stop you, fail fast, fail forward, and move on, and share your lessons. And Iโm very excited to see that alive in Detroit. You heard Jack Dorsey talk aboutโtech gets that. Now we need our communities to get that as they try to innovate.
Finley: Well, you talk about risk-taking in philanthropy almost in the same way that a venture capital fund might, and Rip, is that a suitable model for foundations, particularly ones that are accountable a board and are several generations old and used to doing things a certain way?
Rapson: Well, it is not, it is not easyโI mean, youโre right. I mean, I think when youโve got decades of tradition, of giving in a more responsive way, waiting for the community to sort of package ideas, bring them to you, you do grant reviews, you do your due diligenceโthat still goes on, but I think what Jean is describing is a sort of a much more forward-leaning approach to this kind of giving. And what I would say is that, philanthropic risk for a large private foundation actually is a little bit different, it seems to me, because I think that some of the things that we can do are a little bit more subtle. For example, we spent $50 million dollars to help create a light rail system here in Detroit. I mean, at some level.
Case: Yeah! Thatโs risk-taking!
Rapson: Thank you. You know, at some pointโitโs a little crazy. Philanthropies are probably not supposed to be building railroads, but the idea was, it was a different form of risk. It wasnโt so much the risk that the rail system wouldnโt work, or wouldnโt generate the ridership, or it wouldnโt ultimately be builtโbecause all that stuff could kind of fall in placeโit was trying to create the kind of foundation, the base, so that the private markets felt that their risks would ultimately pay off. So when Dan Gilbert moved however many thousands of people downtown, one of the things he said to me, and to his employees is, โI would not move you downtown in the absence of a light rail system.โ Well, Dan wasnโt going to build thatโand he actually ended up helping build it, butโthe idea is that philanthropy is, I think large, private, legacy philanthropy can sometimes take those big, sort of almost infrastructure risks, that invite the market back.
Finley: Well, what sort of pushback did you get? Because infrastructure building is not what you traditionally do at a foundation. If you support cultural institutionsโand you did, through the bankruptcy with the Grand Bargainโbut, you support cultural institutions, health initiatives, education, what have youโas you said, you donโt build rail. What sort of pushback did you get from your board and from those who sort of might have felt theyโre not going to get their checks because of this?
Rapson: Yeah, I think it was sort of, what kind of pushback did we not get? I mean, it was pretty remarkable. I mean, the federal government had never dealt with a private, philanthropic rail system before. They didnโtโthey had to change all their regulations to prevent monies to flow. The city felt that we were in their space. The state government felt that there wasnโt enough statewide support to do this, I mean, so it wasโand I think if I understand Jeanโs point correctly, is that it is that sort of calculation of risk that is so important. I mean, you can line all that stuff up and say, โToo hard. Too big. Too unorthodox.โ Or you can kind of lean in and then try to sort of adapt as you go, and I think thatโs the sense in which itโs a little bit more like venture, is that you really sort of have to stick your neck out. We can take risks all the time, on an individual grantee or an individual project, but when you get into the public space, when you get into traditional private sector space, market space, I think it does involve a very different kind of educating people about your role, including your board. I mean, it was a big problem with our board. They were very uncomfortable with this.
Finley: Well, Iโd like to hear from both of you on what different type of foundation infrastructure does it take to operate this way versus the traditional way foundations operate. Jean?
Case: Well, I want to say, you know, weโve told a lot of folks to take a look at Kresge as a model, because we think they found a really beautiful balance between the role of a more traditional foundation and where they can lean in and take risksโand Iโll let Rip answer how he sort of changed his organizationโbut I think at the end of the day what weโre seeing play out here in Detroit holds great potential across the nation in communities, because when a foundation comes along next to federal government, so now youโve got a private-public partnershipโor a local government, I should sayโboth have de-risked the other a little bit.
Rapson: Yeah.
Case: So even though both are taking risks, youโve limited the otherโs risk by playing together, and there just hasnโt been enough of this in the communities around the United States, and I think this is where weโre excited. And when we talk about risk, and because I talk about it a lot as part of our Be Fearless movement, itโs really important to point out that weโre talking about measured risk. Weโre not talking about reckless risk here. And for every organization and every leader and every board, thatโs going to feel different. For some it might be one project a year that theyโre willing to kind of lean in or take a big risk. Weโve seen some other foundations say, โHeck no. Itโs going to be most of our portfolio.โ And so, Nolan, depending on where they land on that spectrumโso because weโre very comfortable, and part of our role as a foundation is weโve said weโll go out first, weโll take the arrows in the back, and then weโll publish everything weโve learned in the hopes that some will follow. So we have a very risk-tolerant, entrepreneurial team at the Case Foundation. Other foundations have a very different balance, and Iโll let Rip speak to how he manages that balance.
Rapson: Can I just pivot just a little bit off of Jeanโs comment, because I think ecology in a place is really important. If Kresge is going to invest in a light rail system or in an entrepreneurial ecology, or in a riverfront development, we really canโt do that work unless someone is doing more safety network, other people are doing more health-based work. I mean, I think whatโs interesting about the emerging philanthropy of tech firms and other sort of next-generation philanthropy is that theyโre prepared to sort of move into spaces that philanthropy, in its traditional forms, hasnโt covered. And so what you get is this really interesting ecology. I think as risk-embracing as we might be, we wouldnโt do a lot of the stuff that Jean is doing. I mean, itโs really edgy, interesting, thoughtful stuffโbut knowing that she is doing it permits us to line up our effort a little bit differently.
Finley: All right, I want to just stop and say weโre going to take questions from the audience here in a few minutes here, so if you have a questions, you want to start moving to the microphones up front, because, again, this is a short panel, we donโt to waste a minute of it.
But Jean, you talked about engaging entrepreneurs in philanthropy and foundation work.
Case: Absolutely.
Finley: Whatโs the thinking behind that, and how is it working?
Case: Well, really, when you look at our communities today, as I said, we really need new solutions to old problems. And really to get there, I think thereโs a recognition that we need a different kind of table, different people around the table. Another analogy Iโve used is, we need all the oars in the water, and typically, when we look at those who have been at work trying to solve the issues in our communities, it hasnโt necessarily included the business community. Maybe a company has CSR they throw over the wall, but it hasnโt necessarily involved the passion, the entrepreneurial talent and imagination for new solutions and innovation that entrepreneurs usually bring to the party. So this idea of having entrepreneurs at the table, philanthropy at the table, the public sector, those on the front lines as citizens, and probably the most powerful thing that technology can do is bring the citizenโs voice to the table. So instead of those solutions being drawn on a whiteboardโand you guys followed this very carefully here in Detroitโinstead of those solutions being drawn by a bunch of folks, you know, under fluorescent lights, you bring the people that youโre actually trying to serve, bring their ideas in, bring their voice in. And these technology platforms are enabling that unlike weโve ever seen before, and itโs very exciting.
Finley: And Rip, you talk about strategic partnerships, so not just writing a check and then waiting for the next request to come in the door. Youโre following your money through the process, and often providing much more than the check and the money.
Rapson: Well, I think you have to. I mean, I donโt mean to dwell on the rail project, but I think our money, in many ways, was the least important part of our contribution. We dedicated staff time to talking with the Federal Transit Administrator, to pulling together a statewide coalition, to working with people to get legislation passed at the state level. I think it becomes much more than just writing the check.
Finely: And before we go to questions here, I just wanted to talk, as much as you can, about this Grand Bargain that the foundations led, and really was a lynchpin to getting Detroitโs bankruptcy moving toward a relatively painless solution, not a painless solution, but certainly not as bad as we thought. How did big foundations end up in the middle of a bankruptcy, and end up basically offering the solution?
Rapson: Well itโsโfor those of you who arenโt following every nanosecond of this conversation, we had to solve for two problems. The State of Michiganโs Constitution protects the impairment of pensions, so you canโt impair pensions; itโs a problem if you want to reduce them. And on the other side, the creditors were saying, we want to reach the assets of the Detroit Institute of Art, you sell a Van Gogh, youโre done and free and clear. Well, both of those things would have been litigated into eternity. It just, it would have been impossible, the bankruptcy would have completely fallen apart, and so the chief mediator, the Federal District Judge, came to a couple of us in philanthropy and said, โI have this great idea. If you can aggregate enough money, we can help the pensions not have to take reductions, and we can essentially transfer the money, for all practical purposes to the city, theyโll then buy the Institute of Art and put it into nonprofit status.โ I mean, so you would sort of solve for both problem. I said, โWell, thatโs fine. How much do you have in mind?โ He said, โOh, I donโt know. $500, $800 million should do it.โ โReally? Thatโs interesting. Donโt call me. Iโll call you.โ
Rapson: Andโbut then I got on the phone to one of the really great new figures in philanthropy, Darren Walker, whoโs the head of the Ford Foundation, and Darren said to me, he said, โRip, these are crazy numbers,โ he said,โ But at the end of the day, it would be philanthropic malpractice for us not to at least consider something that could essentially expedite the cityโs exit from bankruptcy.โ So we agreed that I couldnโt do it unless Ford could do it, Ford couldnโt do it unless Krege could do it, so they put in $125 million dollars, we put in $100 million dollars, over and above our other commitments to the city of Detroitโwe ended up assembling about a dozen foundations, put in almost $400 million dollars, the State of Michigan put in another couple of hundred. The Detroit Institute put in a hundred, and all of sudden we were near $900 million dollars, which solved for both of those problems.
And I think in many ways, itโs exactly what Jean was talking about. Sometimes you just have to step outside your comfort zone, be fearless, not think too much about the consequencesโwe were asked all the time, โWell why wouldnโt you do this in Dayton, or why wouldnโt you do this in Columbus?โ You justโthatโs the paralysis stuff. You just have to leap in.
Finley: And Jean, that fits the Be Fearless.
Case: It really does. And A big part of that, that he just mentioned, is collaboration. You know, we talked before about how we de-risk it if you have more people in the game. You just gave a great example of what that looks like. But collaboration among philanthropies and governments has not really happened, for the most part. Philanthropies have called their non-profits to collaborate, but they havenโt been particularly good at it themselves.
And so itโs one of the reasons we love this model. We think theyโre demonstrating maybe a new model that can go forward in a lot of different places, so philanthropies and the public sector working together.
Finley: Okay. And weโve got a question, Jeanette?
Bearse: Hi, Jeanette Pierce, D-Hive. Thank you so much for all of the support from the foundations to the city. We really appreciate it. My question is, how do you balance the new investment that you might be doing with the long term? So Iโve heard some conversation lately, just I guess in the community, around foundations alwaysโseemingly, at leastโgoing towards, sometimes, the shiny new toy. And, but what about the existing programs, and I guess part of that is, how long would you give that shiny new toy? Is it a one-time thing? Is it five years? And I guess just balancing all that timing, of old and new investments.
Case: Well, we probably have different answers to that. The Case Foundation is a catalyst investor. We know going in, weโre not going to be in there for the long haul, and our grantees know that as well, but weโre usually trying to do proof points. Usually thereโs not data, necessarily, to say that something is a good idea, so other philanthropies might be less willing to invest. We give it usually about three years. We have a very rigorous process in which we measure the performance of these investments. If they fail, we tell the world, this is what didnโt work. If they work, we say this is what worked beautifully. And if itโs somewhere in between, we try to tell that story as well. But weโre very much explicit and intentional that weโre not 20-year grantors. Weโre usually in for three years, to model as a catalyst the potential in places across the nation and the world.
Rapson: Yeah, and I think thatโs one of the reasons this ecology is so important, becauseโalthough I suspect that weโre equally seduced by the shiny new toyโwe really are in it for the long term. Our Grand Bargain commitment is 20 years. We developed an operating support program for the arts ecology in Detroit, both the large, the mezzo and the small organizations in Detroit, that we anticipate will go for 20 years. Weโve funded the riverfront since its inception. We will fund it, probably another 15 or 20 years. The human service organizations in town have no other place to turn. We have to be there. So my sense is that even though we want to similarly do catalytic things when itโs required, I think, again, a large, national philanthropy with local roots almost has an obligation to stay the course. So I think we tend to think in terms of a much longer horizon line and realize that the kind of fabric that youโve described is something that has to be nurtured carefully over a very long period of time.
Audience: Good afternoon. I know the Case Foundation, the Kresge Foundation, you guys do a lot of social impact grants, doing a lot of communal stuff. And I know the big issue or obstacle that the impact investing community is facing is, how do you measure the success of a social impact? So I want to ask, what metrics do you all use when making these grants, and then how does the impact the screening process, as well as the relationship you guys have after making those investments?
Case: Yeah, so we have a rigorous business planning process. Our team competes for business planning every year. As part of the business plan, the expect return on investment is articulated, or where we want to see impact, and then we set about to measure that. And I have to say, that sounds really perfect, and itโs a very imperfect system that we have, because often, much like start-ups, where we start out with an investment, we realize maybe six months into it, you know what, if we pivoted and did this instead over here, we think it could have greater impact. So sometimes we have that, you know, same kind of pivoting and changing the business plan along the way, but generally, we have a memorandum of understanding with anyone that we grant to, and we work together to understand what are the impacts weโre after, and measure those along the way.
Rapson: At the risk of sidestepping the question just a little bitโwe every year, Kresge gives out about $150 or $160 million dollars of grants. I like to think that each one of those is some form of impact investing, and that youโre really sort of taking an organization or an idea or a movement apart and putting it back together to understand where it can have the greatest impact. But what has changed in the last five or six years, I think, in, again, a national, private philanthropy, is the idea that you can probably use that grant base to leverage up into loans, direct equity investments, guarantees, and so weโve set aside $30 million dollars a year, which is 20% of our, above and beyond our normal giving, to exactly that kind of purpose, but what weโve insisted on is that itโs integrated with the base. That we donโt just go get the shiny new object because itโs a social impact bond, that we actually try to say whether itโs in our health program, our environmental programโwhat is our program trying to accomplish? And are there circumstances in which a loan or a direct equity investment would actually accelerate the take-up of the idea?
Itโs really hard work, and Nolan asked earlier, do you have to change your staffing model? I didnโt really answer the question. The answer is, absolutely. We had to bring people onboard who understood how to construct these kinds of transactions. It is not something that traditional program staff know how to do.
Finley: Did you have to change your accountability methods as well?
Rapson: Huh. Thatโs an interesting question. Yes. I mean, it begins to look a lot more like our investment portfolio than it does, like, our grant portfolio. We have to risk rate, we have to make sure that the maturation of the loans isnโt skewed, that, you knowโall sorts of different accountabilities, all up and down the line have to get superimposed.
Case: Yeah, and I think for purposes of clarity, it might be good to point out that weโre kind of talking about two different things, right?
Rapson: Yeah, yeah.
Case: One is the grant work, and there itโs pretty straightforwardโyour memorandum of understanding and what impacts youโre seeing. But this exciting new area, impact investingโand if you didnโt see the G7 just came out with a report yesterday summarizing some early activity in the countries involved around the potential here. And this is where foundations money, whether it be money that was designated for grants or investments out of their corpusโwhich is, you know, their core assetsโcan be used to fund companies and private-sector things that are driving the same change they want to see, through grants. We think that holds great promise.
Finley: We have time for one more questions, right here.
Douglas: Hi, Alicia Douglas, of PIP of Detroit, and I just came back from SOCAP and Jean, I know your team was out there, Rip, your team was out there. And this is the exact conversation that we need to be starting here in Detroit, really, on howโnot social impact bonds, but actually impact investingโ
Case: Correct.
Douglas: โcan really start transforming our communities, as well as our ecosystems. And Jean, I know youโre doing some great stuff with Pacific Ventures out in California, and how youโve partnered with them, as well as some public-private partnerships. And so maybe youโd like to give everybody an example with that? And also Iโd like to ask you, Rip, with what youโre going to be doing here in Detroit, to grow that ecosystem with impact investing, and how youโre going to be able to get that funding to local social entrepreneurs that have ideas, that we can be addressing some of the challenges that weโre being faced with in our communities. Thank you so much.
Case: Sure. SOCAP, for those of you that donโt know, is short for Social Capital, and itโs kind of like the impact investing conference that takes place every year out in San Francisco. So I think that G7 report that I just referenced, I had the privilege of serving on the U.S. advisory board for that, so I helped put the U.S. report together, and as I said, I think we see a lot of potential here. But at the launch of that report in June at the White House, we pulled together $2 billion dollars in new commitments to impact investing, and much of this money intended to go into new start-ups, new companies that are committing to provide both a social return as well as a financial return. And this area is a burgeoning area, itโs growing, and we have a lot of early leaders, like Kresge, whoโve been at the table with investments for some time. Our foundation has participated in impact investing, but my husband and I personally have as well, where weโve invested in companies that are trying to address social challenges where there isnโt enough investment, either from the public sector or from philanthropy. Do you want to add anything, Rip?
Rapson: Well, I just think this is one of the 10,000 reasons that Jean and Steve are so incredibly important, is that I think theyโre modeling a set of behaviors that will tug private philanthropy out of its comfort zone. I mean, for a long time there has been a complete Chinese wall between the grant side and the investment side, and weโve sort of begun, sort of chipping away at that wall through PRIs, but the real payoff is when the $4 billion dollars of Kresgeโs assets begin to be put into play for all of our program. And thatโs a long step, but itโs a step that Ford and Kresge and Heron and a number of other national foundations are beginning to take. I probably should have a longer conversation about what weโre going to do here in Detroit, but I think what you can see is that social investing in Detroit requires a pipeline, and for a long time we didnโt have one, nor did we have effective delivery mechanisms on the ground. And I think both of those are emerging, and if there is a sort of an unstated story in Detroit, it is all of a sudden these investable propositions are growing like crazy, and we now increasingly have the capacityโthrough CDFIs and through othersโto get that money deployed effectively. So I actually think itโs not as far a reach, from here on out, to identify philanthropic capital that can push into those channels.