Keen: Thank you all for coming. The subject todayโand I donโt think you can have a counter-reaction. A reaction is counter by definition. So anyway, thatโsโso maybe weโll have to cancel that. But weโre still going to do this. And I thought we would startโweโll try to keep it as informal as we possibly can, keep everybody awake for an hour. I wanted to start, and you can read the bios and all the rest of it if you want in the program, so Iโm not going to do any of that. But I wanted to start with ConstantijnโIโm not even going to try and pronounce his last name. He can do it himself if he wants.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Constantijnโs the difficult part.
Keen:ย Yeah, Constantijnโs hard enough for me, but the last one is even harder. And heโs from the European Commission. Heโs part of the cabinet of Vice President Neelie Kroes. And I thought he would be an interesting beginning because I think heโs going to explain why the title or the description of this panel doesnโt work. So maybe you could start.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Again, Iโm put in the role of the negative one.
Keen: You have a counter-reaction.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Yeah, yeah, I have a counter-reaction. I think probably what I talk about is a counter-reaction to the open Internet, and the global Internet, the non-divided Internet. I donโt really see that as such a counter-reaction to the Internet per se. I think we are maturing in the way of how weโre discussing the use of the Internet and behavior on the Internet, like we did also in the offline world. And I think sometimes we overreact a bit when governments get involved. For instance, I remember when the European Commission proposed to allow to block, or to actually force to block websites that had child pornography. Immediately there was a big counter-reaction, saying how can you block freedom of speech? And these kind of conversations are a bit odd if you are dealing in the normal world. So sometimes we overreact to anything that deals with the Internet, that limits it, also privacy discussions we tend to take into a very existential domain, as if the Internet is being closed down or something.
Keen: Theresa Swinehart from ICANN. Exaggeration, Theresa? Is there really an existential threat here in terms of someone out there, some dark force, whether itโs Erdogan or Putin or someone in China or Iran shutting this whole thing down?
Swinehart: No, no, I actually agree. I think that we actually have to look at this as itโs a disruptive technology, itโs changed business models, itโs changed power struggles, and it is not a model or a medium that can be managed in the same way as other things, because of the decentralized nature. And so it creates situations of chaos, it creates situations of ambiguity about how we solve for issues. And so I agree, we tend to have extreme reactions in some things. Then it has to cater itself out in order to figure out how to solve certain issues. I think the Putin thing, I think the Facebook issues are all things that are going to come up. Weโll have to work to find solutions around it. But I think this is all about change and a disruptive technology.
Keen: So Theresa, very, very briefly, whatโs going on here? What should we be talking about today? What is worrying and what are issues that we collectively perhaps can influence?
Swinehart: So I actually think the most important thing is the conversations around how to retain an Internet thatโs not fragmented. ICANN deals with the addressing space, so itโs a single root, itโs a single global Internet, but I think many of the issues coming up for discussion have a risk of fragmenting the Internet at the content layers, at the service layers, and I think the conversation that we need to be having is how to be forward thinking on solving problems without disrupting the Internet overall.
Keen:ย David, youโre the co-founder and CEO of AnchorFree, a technology company that reunites orโI donโt know what the opposite of Balkan is, maybe Austro-Hungary or something.
[LAUGHTER]
But youโre in the business of solving this problem. Is it just a technology problem or is it a political problem? What does your company, what does AnchorFree do?
Gorodyansky: AnchorFree is the worldโs largest Internet freedom and privacy platform. About 300 million people around the world have downloaded our app, Hotspot Shield, to gain uncensored access to all the worldโs information and security and privacy. I think the answer to your question is that itโs a mix between product and policy. Itโs got to be both. But I want to deemphasize the importance of policy a little bit, because I think a lot of people think that as long as weโve got these think tanks talking about policy all day longโand Iโve spent enough time with people in D.C. to know that youโve got all these great policy discussions, but they donโt really go anywhere. If the CTO of Microsoft comes out and says, โIโm going to condense my privacy policy from 12 pages to twoโ or something, nobodyโs going to read that, right? So from my perspective, itโs got to be a balance between policy and product, but I think product is a lot more effective and efficient.
Keen: But youโre a for-profit company, so youโre empowering people to sort of hide behind masks of anonymity. Some people might say thatโs the problem rather than the solution.
Gorodyansky: Providing people with control over their personal privacy and access to information are both basic human rights according to the United Nations. So I would say that itโs a solution, and itโs an important one because we live in a world where we have a lot of entities that want our data. We have 11 million Americans had their identities stolen last year. Millions of China Mobile users had their identities stolen last year. I think 40 percent of Internet users in Brazil had some kind of threats over unsecured Wi-Fi networks. And so at some point itโs very hard to distinguish between threats from malware, identity thieves, websites trying to collect our personal information, or governments. And at some point I think the citizens of the world have to just stand up and say, โLook, nobodyโs really going to protect my data except for me.โ
Keen: Barton, is that the challenge, citizens of the world standing up and demanding privacy? Youโre an expert on the NSA. You were one of the earliest people that Edward Snowden was talking to. Is the problem here one of privacy in terms of this supposedly Balkanized Internet?
Gellman: Itโs a question of power, I think. Information is power, communication is power. Letโs look at the long-term trend here. Internet begins as this decentralized, very independent force, almost sort of without much notice from government. So thereโs the famous John Perry Barlow Declaration of Independence of the Internet, you know, we donโt care about you, governments, andโ
Keen: Which he made, by the way, from Davos.
Gellman: Yes. And, you know, the famous cartoon, โOn the Internet, no one knows youโre a dog.โ Now everyone knows youโre a dog, and everyone wants to know where youโre wandering around the neighborhood. And so you would say that the reaction was that large institutions, for economic and political reasons, tried to impose controls on the Internet. Theโ
Keen:ย Which is understandable, right?
Gellman: Well itโs certainly understandable from the point of view of their incentives. It may not be optimal. So it went something like a VPN, a virtual private network does, or more slowly butโpardon the expression, but I would argue more securely, the Tor network doesโand Facebook just put in a Tor address. It does two fundamental things. It allows you to be much more anonymous, and it allows you to circumvent censorship, because whoeverโs sort of watching the pipes and watching your data go by, itโs very hard for them to know who you are, where you are, and where youโre going. And so if China wants to tell you youโre not allowed to go to Facebook, or if the BBC wants to tell you that from New York you canโt watch its shows, you switch on one of these things and you appear to be coming from somewhere else. So itโs a user empowerment technology.
Keen: KPโ
zu Guttenberg: T.
Keen: T. Nearly right. KT.
zu Guttenberg: Two letters, thatโsโ
Keen: And weโve got our two Europeans to my left, perhaps not un-coincidentally.
[LAUGHTER]
KT, is this theโbecause youโre an expert on the relationship between the U.S. and Europe over tech policy and youโre sort of, youโre somewhere in between. Youโre a mid-Atlantic character. Is the big issueโat least when it comes to the U.S. and Europeโprivacy, the thing that Barton and David are talking about, or is there something more profound? Maybe there isnโt something more profound than privacy.
zu Guttenberg: It is certainly a different perception of privacy on both sides of the Atlantic, which we havenโt resolved yet. And itโs also a different perception of the interrelation of privacy and security, again, the perception of security as well on both sides. So there we havenโt found any common ground yet, andโ
Keen: We havenโt?
zu Guttenberg: No, we havenโt.
Keen: None at all?
zu Guttenberg: I donโtโspecifically if I look at my home country, Germany, and the U.S., where letโs say the outcry of disgust was probably one of the most remarkable ones in those times, I donโt see very much common ground. Then we have a political problem, probably on both sides. So we have mentioned it already, and it goes along withโand I have been for quite a while in government. It goes along with a dramatic lack of knowledge when it comes to the details of what weโre talking about here.
Swinehart: Itโs true.
zu Guttenberg: Theyโre still scratching on the surface. The speed of politics, or the pace of politics doesnโt really allow to dive into it substantially. And that goes along with another problem, and thatโs probably the emotional problem you may have specifically countered, after the NSA revelations, again on the other side of the Atlantic probably more than over here. So itโs a couple of levels we have to face here, as well as a certain amount of levels of hypocrisy.
Keen: But do you believe in the ideaโand maybe we can go along the panel here, from left to right. Do you believe in the idea of common ground, or is that just another sort of self-serving Silicon Valley ideology as it colonizes the world? What does common ground mean?
zu Guttenberg: It could also be a self-serving European ideology. Soโ
Keen: Or both.
zu Guttenberg: Maybe both. So I donโt seeโI would not pretend that we come to a solution where we would happily embrace each other on every single topic we are talking about. But there are a couple of things where I do at least see potential trans-Atlantic common grounds, because there are a couple of things we really do share in perception and perspectives. And I do see, actuallyโ
Keen:ย What? Give me specific.
zu Guttenberg: Well for instance, the whole question of how to deal with and to counter also others like Russia and China, of how to deal with industrial espionage, for instance. Thatโs a thing where we could start with after the whole NSA revelations we have been in. We could find common ground when it comes the topic of how to get into some encryption commonalities. Itโs why not doing that together, and why not starting with the European Commissionโ
Keen: Constantijn, common ground. Tell me whereโyouโre a special advisorโwhere there really is genuine common ground, potentially, between the U.S. and Europe? And are you as pessimistic about the, at the moment at least, the complete absence of any common ground when it comes to Internet policy, global Internet policy?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well I donโt agree that thereโs a complete absence. I think you were talking about a specific part before, on privacy, where in the negotiations and at a trade level there are difficulties finding common ground. But if you look at where, yes, the philosophy might be different, but I think American citizens care a lot about privacy, European citizens care a lot about privacy, and finding maybe different ways of dealing with that. I think if we look atโif we take a step back and we look at the world, thereโs no market than the European and the Americans that have more in common and are exchanging more data than which other market in the world. So if weโre talking about commonality, I think itโs in both our interest, but also interest in how the Internet develops, that Europe and the U.S. find common ground in how to exchange data. And I think itโs happening already, and sometimes weโre over-exaggerating the actual differences. And I think most companies, bigger U.S. companies are doing very well in Europe. Sometimes the Europeans are actually complaining, because the Americans have maybe lower regulatory burdens and are coming to Europe and have deeper pockets to cross borders where the Europeans donโt. So I think a lot ofโI think itโs up to our interest in Europe to keep our markets open, open to U.S. companies, but also other companies in the world.
Keen: So some people are considering closing the European market to U.S.? Is that what youโre saying?
Van Oranje-Nassau: No, but sometimes in the rhetoric, thatโs what youโre hearing.
Keen: What do you mean? From who?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well, the title of this thing isโyou seem to equate authoritarian regimes with a privacy policy in Europe thatโs closing down the Internet. I mean I find that a bit absurd, butโ
Keen: Theresa?
Swinehart: So I think this is raising a whole slew of issues. You know, whether you have innovative markets or whether you have common ground and values and solutions to that. But I think itโs interesting to have a conversation between the U.S. and across the Atlantic, but thereโs emerging economies that are the Internet users of the future and how one actually finds common ground to dealing with issues that respect the values of different cultures around the world, I think itโs a challenge. And I think itโs going to be a very hard challenge, but I think it is doable.
Keen: Give me some examples. What does that mean?
Swinehart: The privacy issue, for example, or the cybersecurity issue, or the trade issue, or content and whatโs acceptable content and whatโs not acceptable content across national jurisdictions. And so we have to find solutions that are scalable globally, that bring parties together, that respect the values, that allow for the investments into the markets and the innovation that needs to be taking place. And frankly, thatโs not easy. It gets noisy.
Keen: But you believe that there are, in terms of knitting this thing together, that collectively, in theory, we have common ground?
Swinehart: Yes, I do. Yes.
Keen: On everything?
Swinehart: No, not on everything.But I think if one takes the premise of does one want to keep a global Internet, does one want to allow the cross-services across different jurisdictions, does one want to respect values of different countries and priorities of different countries, I think if one takes some basic principles, and starts working toward solutions in that areaโitโs utopian and, yes, maybe itโs a bit theoretical, but I think it is workable.
Keen: Barton, do we want to keep a global Internet? How does that connect with your work?
Gellman: Well, as someone who communicates for a living and wants a wide readership, Iโm all for a global Internet in that way. Iโmโas someone who seeks information, I count on the least possible impediment to my seeking that information, so of course I think thatโs a good thing. I donโt have a lot of sympathy for either governments or private companies that want to say that youโre allowed to talk to this one and this one but not that one, youโre allowed to read this and this but not that. And to the extent the argument is about that sort of sovereign control over citizen behavior, Iโm not interested.
Keen: But letโs say you were to turn your considerable critical talents to doing a book about China or Russia. Wouldnโt it be kind of inevitable that that work wouldnโt be as accessible there as it is here?
Gellman: Well, I understand all their incentives. I know whyโI mean, theyโand theyโre complicated, because they need a considerable flow of open information in order to be successful in their experiments with controlled capitalismโand I guess youโd no longer call it an experiment. I mean, they have a relatively free market economy that needs information, and they have a relatively unfree political system that requires control of communications and of what they would regard as potential plots against their monopoly on power. So I mean, I understand why they want it. I donโt see why weโd want to collaborate in helping them obtain it.
Keen: So but, David, youโagain, coming back toโis the common ground technology like yours, really technologyโagain, coming back to this original questionโis technology the solution, or do we need politics as well?
Gorodyansky: I think itโs a combination of both. I think technology is more scalable than politics and can travel across borders faster. But I also think that the narrative has to change here from self-interest to global interest, to common interest. I think the United States and Europe and the rest of the world have to really say, โLook, we no longer have self-interest. Our interests are global.โ
Keen:ย But thatโs easy to say if youโre like you and your self-interest and global interest are the same thing.
Gorodyansky: Well, I mean the reality is that we are, itโs a fact. So if we keep on thinking about self-interest, let me just ask you guys, and just take a step back from the conversation on privacy, is climate change a U.S. issue or a European issue, or a Brazilian issue, or an African issue? The worldโs biggest global challenges are global. And weโve got to address them by working with the world, not by protecting or promoting our own self-interest. Thatโs the only way forward.
Keen:ย Theresa, is the best argument for keeping an open Internet, a global Internet, is it an economic argument rather than a moral one? Do we all get richer if we create this common ground or is there something more philosophical here at issue?
Swinehart: So itโs not just an economic argument, though the economic arguments are pretty strong. I mean 2.5 GDP growth on average on an Internet thatโs global is pretty strong. But I think if one looks at the societal norms, the opportunities for education in the next generation, healthcare opportunities, dialogues that are happening at this conference about different tools that are out there that are existing because of the Internet, I think itโs actually the next generation of opportunity and itโs our choice to either continue to allow the innovation to be occurring or not to be occurring, but the opportunities are going to be missed.
Keen: Constantijn, do you agree? Is that what youโre finding in Europe?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well, yes, of course. Butโ
Keen: Why do you say โof courseโ?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Because well, you know when you use the Internet youโre trying toโyou get your services from across borders, you get information from across borders, so you do want informationโitโs not just about business, itโs about how youโre interacting with friends. Youโre probably all on Facebook because it connects you with your global set of contacts, instead of going for a national social media platform. So I think that seems quite obvious. But I think for governments that have the option between closing down because they are maybe authoritarian and they wantโso they have a political view on the one hand. The moment that they start to get integrated in the global Internet commercially, they will have to start weighing their options. So with Alibaba, for instance, the Chinese e-commerce company, actually theyโre going beyond the borders of China. I think thatโs a strong incentive for the Chinese also to start to think, or to think about how they play their cards in the global Internet game and if they want to be part of retaining and strengthening the global Internet or if they want to play on this Balkanization scenarioโ
Keen: And doesnโt Europe have the worst of both worlds? You donโt really have many Internet companies, and everythingโs coming from America, and yet youโre sort of open at the time, whereas at least Russia or China shut their markets off and they are able to build indigenous Internet companies.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well this question is so far beyond my understanding that I donโt really know how to answer it. But, no, Iโ
Keen: Well, but Europe has struggled to createโI mean, Googleโs got more market share in Italy or Spain or France, I think, than it has in the U.S..
Van Oranje-Nassau: Yet, itโs providing good service, so why would we cut off our consumers from good service?
Keen: KT, common ground? Where does it lie? What are you seeing? Youโre a mid-Atlantic guy. I mean, aside from privacyโ
zu Guttenberg: A left-sitting mid-Atlantic guy. One common ground would be, going back to the question is it self-interest or global interest, I would always say itโs both. And thatโs one of the things we need to understand. You will not find a single government around the globe which will not combine self-interest with a certain amount of global interest. So the self-interest will always play into it. And the self-interest of course is then tied to certain election cycles, and where itโs extremely easy to play the populist card. And this is one of the things we need to see from a realistic point of view as well. We can dream a lot about where to get together, where to find common ground. But then we have to analyze the players involved, and the players involved are governments against governments. Itโs foreign governments against American tech companies, itโs governments against its own tech companies. So itโs not the broad brush stroke that helps here, itโs actually trying to cut it down toโ
Keen: Give me some examples of companies or governments which have balanced global and self-interest which would be a model for moving forward.
zu Guttenberg: Well I donโt see the role model yet, as such, but I think there is a potential in this country and thereโs a potential in certain European countries as well. Constantijn has just mentioned China. I think China is on an interesting way, and we should not counter-react immediately as we hear about China that this is probably the worst-case scenario weโre facing right now. It could be actually an interesting case.
Keen: And Theresa, you have someโI think, following on, your idea of the Great Wall of China, which is sort of conveniently porous, might be a model. Is that fair?
Swinehart: I wouldnโt say itโs a model, but I would go to the point that Constantijn has made about they are engaging. So they have businesses, they are developing businesses, theyโre going to cross borders. Weโre certainly finding in some of the international fora and discussions around Internet policy issues, including ICANN, that they are sending very senior officials and very strong participants. So I think that thereโs an emergence of a realization of the value of engaging and participating in the Internet space, in Internet companies, versus also the point around self-interest and how do you strike that balance. But thatโs for respective countries and governments to find the solutions for. But weโre certainly finding engagement, including from Iran, by the way.
Keen: Are you horrified by this, Barton, the idea of even mentioning the Great Wall of China in a vaguely positive way?
Gellman: I donโt feel sufficiently qualified. I mean, if you want to take aโ
Keen: Well youโre saying itโs sort of a moderate kind of censorship, butโ
Swinehart: Look, itโs a model that China has chosen to use. Whether one agrees with it or not, it is the choice of the country, and itโs the choice of the country to see whether it has an impact on their economic growth or not. Itโs certainly evident that there have been workarounds. People still communicate, companies still evolve. Thereโs probably less stringent controls now than potentially there were before. So I think one sees a shift. But itโs for the country to determine whether they want that or not.
Gellman: I mean one way to look at what Chinaโs doing is it is blocking content and blocking communications behavior for the great majority of people in a way that, if youโre sufficiently interested and determined, you can get around. And Facebook has just made a very interesting move on this, byโso Iโll just explain slightly more for those who arenโt familiar. Tor is a U.S.-developed technology to anonymize. And thereโs such a thing as a Tor hidden service, which you hear about on the news that itโs being used by drug dealers and such, but itโs also used for lots of other much more beneficial purposes. Facebook has just given itself a Tor hidden service address. Youโre not anonymous to Facebook, you still have to log in, but youโre anonymous to all the points on the Internet between yourself and Facebook. And so the government of China in particular is not going to know whoโs going on Facebook or who they are or where they are, unless it expends enormous effort that so far it has not expended. And thatโs a very interesting move by Facebook, which wants to do business in China, and itโs a liberating move.
Keen: David, youโre originally from Russia. Whatโs your take on whatโs happening there? And I assume that itโs hard to take anything positive out of that, as opposed to the Great Wall of China.
[LAUGHTER]
Gorodyansky: Well, we donโtโyou know, most of our business is here, and really weโve got users in 190 countries, including China. Russiaโs not one of the countries where we have a lot of users. Mainly because they donโt really censor the Internet. China does. So in China, Facebook is censored. Twitter, you canโt get to Twitter, many different news sites, many social networks. Not the case in Russia. We havenโt seen a lot of users from there, we havenโt seen a lot of things get censored.
Keen: Iโm going to have one more round, and then pleaseโyes?
Van Oranje-Nassau: One this on this Tor. So we keep talking about the Internet as the open Internet. Thereโs a lot of people that complain, especially from industry, that thereโs no kind of quality of service Internet or that everybody can enter anonymously, which has actually led to a lot of abuse, and that you canโt ever win the Internet security race, blah, blah, blah, all of that. So theyโre basically calling for an Internet that is IP secured, itโs not anonymous. Do we see now, between Tor and what we currently have, is the open Internet also an Internet emerging that is much more controlled for business purposes, where people are identified, or do we seeโI mean, I donโt know, how does this development evolve? Because Tor is now, as you said, was portrayed as the place where drugs are sold and you can buy your weapons and you can do all these kinds of things. But thatโs what people said about the common Internet as well. They said thereโs this anarchistic space. So are we seeing that the former anarchistic space of the Internet is becoming more controlled and regulated, whereas now we have this new Internet, which is unregulated, and does that mean that the current, say the common Internetโ
Keen: Could you explainโbecause Iโm not sure if everyone here is as hardcore technologist as some of you. What does this mean, Tor, and how does this play out? Could you explain it a bit more?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well maybe your neighbor can more than I can.
Keen: Yeah, David, what does that mean? How does that change things?
Gorodyansky: Sure, so Tor is basically a product that routes your traffic through other computers. So itโs a volunteer networkโ
Gellman: Okay, weโre going to do a little demonstration here. So I want to talk to your water glass, I connect to a Tor node, itโs an encrypted connection. This one passes me to another Tor node, which doesnโt know who I am because it only knows it got it from here. It goes through three nodes, hits the water glass, nobody along the way, except for certainly hypothetical crazyโ
Keen: So itโs a P-to-P form of communication.
Gorodyansky: Itโs a P-to-P form of communication, but the problem with it, as you just saw, is you have three or four hops, so itโs very slow. And so my take on it is mainstream consumers arenโt going to adopt Tor just because itโs relatively slow. And I do think that there isโthere has to be some balance between using something like Tor, which is relatively complicated, and basically not using anything and giving up all of your data. There are times where you want to be private and anonymous, there are times when you donโt. If you go to your bank site, you donโt need to be anonymous. Thereโs no reason to be anonymous on your bankโs site, unless you want to hack it or something. If youโre going to Google or Facebook you may very well want to be anonymous.
Keen: Why? Because of their business model?
Gorodyansky: Yes, because you donโt want them to collect your data. I mean, if you search for healthcare related things on Google, all of the sudden your insurance premium goes up. You donโt want that to happen.
Keen: So Googleโs watching everything we do.
Gorodyansky: Absolutely.
Keen: KT, do you agree onโ
Gellman: One other quick example here why an ordinary person would want privacy. Look, as an investigative reporter, I need privacy to communicate with people confidentially. Human rights workers do, lots of other people do. But I have a Verizon phone. Weโve just learned through security researchers that Verizon Wireless and AT&T are actually injecting code into the data stream of their mobile devices that uniquely identifies me, so theyโre able to track me around the Internet and sell my data. Even though Iโm paying them quite a bit of money for their service, theyโre still harvesting my data and selling it. If I use Davidโs service, a VPN, or if I use Tor on the phone, either of which you could do, then they canโt do that. They canโt inject the code because itโs an encrypted link and they donโt know where Iโm going.
Keen: So youโreโbut how do they respond to that afterwards? Isnโt this a sort of endless cat-and-mouse game of one side does one thing, another side does the next?
Gorodyansky: No, because if we encrypt all the traffic, basically Verizon and AT&T or whoever canโt collect and sell our data. Itโs all encrypted.
Gellman: I mean I feel like itโs an extraordinaryโitโs a betrayal of me as a customer that theyโre doing this to me, or trying to. It would be a whole other universe of betrayal if they took active steps to attack and to break VPN connections of their customers. That would beโthat probably would be unlawful.
Keen: Theresa, youโre the most reasonable person here, I think, in the room. I trust you.
[LAUGHTER]
Swinehart: Thatโs actually quite worrisome.
Keen: Are Verizon and all of these other carriers, are they really reading everything we do?Are we entering, you know, Orwell, Big Brother and all that?
Swinehart: Well actually, I canโt really comment on those specific things, but what I do want to come back to is, weโre actually dealing with a situation now where itโs user choice and user demand, right? And so as weโre looking at some of these different initiatives that are happening and whether people want to be using Google or they want to be using Facebook or whatever it might be, thereโs certain attributes that exist in using those services that users have a choice not to use them if they want to. And so I think thereโs that aspect of it.
I think that thereโs also a bit of a shift in where the roles and responsibilities of the players go. Historically, itโs always been the government may have responsibility to regulate in order to make the world safe. Then it shifted over to corporations may have responsibility. I think the users play a tremendous role in that now on being accountable also to how theyโre using the medium themselves.
Keen: KT, why canโt Europe come up with the anti-Google, or at least the anti-Google business model?
zu Guttenberg: I think there are a couple of interesting ideas floating around, which are not necessarily connected to data secessionism. But an idea Iโve heard about, itโs nothing entirely new and revolutionary, but three or four weeks ago a company popped up that saidโwell itโs actually an American company that wants to move to Europe, because they fear to lose the other markets if they do it from the U.S.โ
Keen: Whatโs the name of the company?
zu Guttenberg: And they said letโs not only go for opt-out opportunities, okay, letโs also go for opt-in opportunities. And itโs nothing that has to do anything with encryption or anonymity. And itโs a tiny little idea and the European ISPs jumped on that idea immediately, soโ
Keen: What do you mean jumped on it? You meanโ
zu Guttenberg: Well they loved it, letโs put it that way.
Keen: But you always hear of these technologies or companies that seem to be solving the problemโwe used to read a lot about DuckDuckGoโbut none of them seem to ever get any traction.
Gellman: DuckDuckGoโs actually got a huge growth attraction.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Microsoft is offering these services of European routing and data localization, so I mean I donโtโ
Keen: Well, what theyโ
Van Oranje-Nassau: Itโs where thereโs a customer base. I think weโre sometimes over-making this a policy thing. I think if there really is a demand for privacy, I think companiesโand for local routing, companies will start offering it. And we saw that. Maybe we sometimes need a wakeup call like Snowden, but I think we should work much more with the market than try to overregulate.
Keen: Was it a wakeup call? I just sawโwe were talking about this. I saw โCitizenfour,โ and Snowden now seems almost like ancient history. Has it really been a wakeup call? Has it changed anything?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well like the banking crisis hasnโt changed banking, yet some people would say that they think it was a wakeup call.
Keen: You agree, Theresa? Was it a wakeup call?
Swinehart: Absolutely.
Keen: Whatโs changed? But a wakeup call means you wake up. Then what happens?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well I mean you have a siesta.
[LAUGHTER]
Keen: You go back to sleep.
Swinehart: Well said.
Keen: But whatโs changed? Why is the world now different a year on, or 18โwhen did the thing break? A year ago, 18โ
Gellman: A year and a half-ish.
Keen: Whatโs changed?
zu Guttenberg: I think amongst or in between governments a lot has changed. Andโ
Keen: But we donโt see that. What does that mean?
zu Guttenberg: From the consumer side, Iโd say theyโre back fast asleep. And so many are.
Keen: But itโs a convenient sleep. They donโt want to be woken up. They donโt want to know the reality, right? So in terms of government, itโs like German-U.S. relations have changed?
zu Guttenberg: Well they have changed not for the better, but this is change, and itโs actually the lousiest relation Iโve seen in the last 15 years between these two countries. Again, it offers opportunities.
Keen: Because of the data stuff?
zu Guttenberg: Because of the data stuff. Not only because of the rusty old cellphone of the Chancellor. Itโs a bit more behind it. But, again, there is a lot of hypocrisy in the game there as well. So of course we found out that the Germans are trying the same. Itโs not as sophisticated as they do over here. Itโs also, from the consumer side, on one hand you give happily away your data, on the other hand you feel compelled by whatโs happening around you. And the private sector as well, itโs an outcry of disgust. How can we be treated as we have been treated by the NSA? And the question is actually are we moving more from government to Google-ment [โฆ] than the other way around? And so itโs [โฆ] But this is the debate weโre in also in Germany and this is a change. I think thatโs a significant change. We wouldnโt have had that discussion about two or three years ago.
Keen: Barton, do we need to wake consumers up? Are they conveniently sleeping, they want all the cool free services and then theyโre not willing to acknowledge what theyโre really paying for this stuff?
Gellman: So Iโll answer that, but I wonder if I could have the privilege also of asking a question also to our European friends.
Keen: Yes, absolutely.
Gellman: But the quick answer is thatโ
Keen: Yes, and please, you know, donโt be mute. Donโt be like consumers. Wake up.
Gellman: Yes, consumers, when itโs a hypothetical question, donโt seem to put a really high value on privacy, although their behavior is much more complex than that. For example, people say teenagers will tell anybody anything. Thatโs not true at all. They might be happy to tell their friends this or that. They donโt want tell their parents or their principle, and so they speak in code. They use song lyrics and so forth on Facebook that they all understand and that we donโt. But when you make it more concrete, when you show someone exactly how much is known about themโIโve done this experiment a couple of times myself on colleagues who didnโt think they cared about privacyโthey have a quite different reaction.
Keen: So whatโs your question?
Gellman: So my question is, in terms of the different conceptions of privacy, it seems clear to me now, and I didnโt understand it before Snowden, that the U.S. government, the intelligence community, and the NSA in particular, does not want to acknowledge the validity of any signal, any content from any place by any person using any forms of self-protection like encryption. That should be out of their reach. They donโt want to know everything about everybody, but they want to be able to know anything about anybody. And so they do it becauseโif I was in their jobs, Iโd probably do it the same. I mean, I would say well my responsibility is unbounded, to know everythingโ
Keen: So question.
Gellman: So is that a difference? Is it that your governments believe there ought to be boundaries, sanctuaries of privacy that governments canโt get into?
Keen: And these guys arenโt the official representatives of Europe, to be fair.
Gellman: And if I could just say, as you mustโas must have occurred to you, thereโs a very high probability that each of you individually has been targeted for collection by NSA.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Itโs an insult not to be targeted.
[LAUGHTER]
Keen: Thatโs no joke.
zu Guttenberg: I take it with a certain pride. I think a major distinction lies in the question whether you come from the side where you accept that you have the power to control or whether you control the power. And the Europeans actually have a veryโso many Europeans actually like the aspect of controlling the power, Germans specifically, due to their history. And I think there lies one of their biggest differences across the Atlantic in that very regard, and where you can also try to find solutions. Itโs one of the things that could add up to something we could see from the complementary side, but itโs a long way to go.
Van Nassau-Oranje: But the tension is I think universal between the intelligence community wanting to have access to everything if they think itโs necessary and other parts of civil society that think that should not be the case. But as you said, if youโre in the shoes of the intelligence agency, you would want to have that access. So that is not either European or American, itโs in how do you organize that. And then we get to the point of controlling the power. So what democratic control do you have over those that seek access to everything? And when they get access, how do you manage that and how accountable are they for it?
Keen: Well letโs have some comments. This lady here.
Westby: Jody Westby from Global Cyber Risk. So we know the NSAโs collecting and we know that governments and intelligence bureaus are also collecting and exchanging. Iโm not supposed to spy on my people, but you can, and Iโll spy on yours and weโll exchange information. But we also know that providers are packet-sniffing for what you were talking about. It is a direct violation of the U.S. code, and they arenโt being called on it. So thatโs one thing is all your trafficโs being sniffed. But the third thing is the governmentโs involvement inโlike with Tor. So remember when they cancelled the Carnegie Mellon presentation where they were going to showโthese researchers were going to show how they could hack into Tor and suddenly that presentation was cancelled. I talked to the lead people at Carnegie Mellon and theyโI was trying to figure out, because thereโs a software engineering instituteโwhich is an FFRDC and federally funded; lots of DoD money goes in thereโand then thereโs academic freedom on the university side. Three days ago all of these people were arrested by federal agents because they broke into Tor. So is Tor safe?
Keen: So whatโs your outrage? Is it against the security services?
Westby: Well itโs against the government, one, suppressing academic freedom. Two, are they in the back of technologies, where they can use it to their benefit and keep it away from the people? And, three, you know, the surveillance. And, four, what the providers are doingโeveryone knows it, and the governmentโs not doing anything about it. So, yeah, Iโm pretty outraged on all fronts.
Keen: Should she be outraged, Theresa?
Westby: Hi, Theresa.
Swinehart: How are you? Itโs good to see you again.
Keen: Should she be outraged?
Swinehart: Well Iโm not familiar with the exact situation, but, yes, it sounds like, you know, this is a problem.
Keen:ย Who else shares this outrage? Be outraged. Are you outraged in the same way as this lady?
Westby: Iโm just more astonished that itโs actually happening.
Swinehart: Yeah, Iโm astonished myself.
Keen: You mean post-Snowden, or just any time?
Westby: Iโm the only person publicly thatโs called on the press repeatedly for an investigation, a full and open investigation. Not another major press, not another civil liberties organization. And why? And the people I talk to, people say, โI donโt care, I have nothing to hide.โ
Keen: Well, Bartonโyouโve got one of the top investigative journalists.
Westby: I know.
Keen: Why donโt you write something about what this ladyโs saying?
Westby: He reported the news but his editorial page wonโt call for the investigation.
Keen: Could you respond to this? This seems to be a major story.
Gellman: Well, several dimensions here. Itโs true, โThe Washington Postโ editorial page has beenโthe opinion people, they really are two completely different hierarchies that donโt overlap at all. So Iโve broken lots of stories about what the NSA is doing in โThe Washington Postโ news pages, and on the editorial pages you have people saying that reporters who break these stories should be put in jail. Iโm actually quite proud of that. I like the very clear demonstration of independence of news from opinion.
As far asโI donโt know enough about, and I respectfully suggest that nobody knows enough yet about why the research presentation on Tor vulnerabilities was cancelled. And I imagine we will learn that over the coming months. And it may just have been postponed. You have these things come up from time to time, at Black Hat or DevCon, or CCC security conferences, where thereโs a scheduled presentation and then it mysteriously disappears, but the research comes out in the end.
And as far as packet-sniffing, which is the practice of your Internet service provider looking deep into the packets, so your digital traffic is busted up into lots of little pieces, and spying on what youโre doing so it can figure out interesting things about you, thatโs exactly what I was talking about before and I hate that.
Keen: Letโs actually, letโs have some more questions or comments about the more global element here, rather than how the governmentโs spying on us, because that seems to be a symptom rather than a cause. I mean I think people get sick of this. I mean how many more stories can you get. Itโs like when the Snowden thing, it was like slow torture. Every day there was, oh, itโs going to get worse and itโs going to get worse, and after a while that just gets boring, right? I mean how much more can we put up with this as news consumers?
Gellman: Well, be patient. My bookโs coming out.
[LAUGHTER]
Keen: This gentleman. You might introduce yourself.
Persson: My name is Michael Persson from the Dutch newspaper De Volkskrant. Yeah, I want to take it back a bit more globally and go back to the title with counter-reaction. One of the cases that weโve seen the last year was the court in Europe, the judge saying that the right to be forgotten should be a definite right for people and their names on the Internet, especially for search machines not to find these people. This is one of the cases where you see a counter-reaction. Thereโs also the other one, a court case against Facebook. And there is a definite difference of opinion between what Europeans think and what Americans think. And especially Google made a very strong case against this outcome and really trying hard to confront this counter-reaction. They make a huge lobby trying to erase this verdict mostly. So my question actually is does the Internet and do tech companies actually allow a counter-reaction or is it a force in itself that is unstoppable, looking at this European resistance?
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well first the right to be forgotten wasnโt held up by the court. The court just said that Google, as a big data company, also falls under this right. And to the credit of Google, they actually made it work. I mean they have started to actually implement it, whereasโI think they are the only company that does it. I guess thereโs a lot of other companies in the same line of business should be doing the same. And European companies as well, but they might not have the infrastructure to do it.
For me itโs an interesting phenomenon, because itโs been there since the late 1990s, this provision. And now itโs implemented because of this court order. And it actually triggered a debate, which is a really interesting one, can you do this? And the more interesting one is, is Google really the arbitrator between what should be forgotten and what not, and can you retroactively, for instance, erase journal articles, you know, media articles about someone because you donโt favor the tone of the article? I think there you have this kind of retroactive editorial roleโ
Keen: Well Michael, youโre a journalist. What do you think?
Persson: I think this right should beโI know a couple of casesโI can right now name one. This was a guy who appealed to Google for his right to be forgotten, it was a guyโactually there was a story in our newspaper in the 1990s. He was featured in this article playing a didgeridoo in Vondel Park in Amsterdam. Very innocent. But whenever anybody types in his name in Google or Yahoo or whatever, the first search result is for him playing a didgeridoo in the Vondel Park, and he looks like a hippie. He tells something about being stoned all the time, which is really relatively innocent in Amsterdam.
[LAUGHTER]
Keen: Half the population.
Persson: But now, 20 years on, heโs not a didgeridoo player anymore, but heโs trying to be a financial consultant or something like this.
[LAUGHTER]
Keen: So youโre sympathetic to him having the right to have that didgeridoo erased, or lowered in the search engine?
Persson: In the end it was honored, I must say. This was honored so this story doesnโt come up anymore in the Dutch domain of Google. If you go to Google.com itโs still there, so I mean the right to be forgotten is really relatively applied by Google. Itโs still on Google.com
Anyway, I think itโs good that this history can be erased. This guy is never in the news and then suddenly heโs reduced to a didgeridoo player, which he is not anymore. Thereโs noโwell I think even as a journalist, and of course finding everyโthe freedom of information and freedom of speech, everything thatโs so very important. But I think in this case itโs not that relevant anymore. The storyโs actually is still sitting in our archives.
Audience: How have you had to remove it.
Persson: Sorry?
Audience: How have you had to remove it?
Persson: We actually, we have removed his surname, so the storyโs in our archives. And if you go to our online archives, the storyโs there without the manโs surname. In the real closed archives, so you wonโt find it on Google search, but in the closed archive itโs still complete. So there, if you want your history, if you want to have our complete information, itโs still there. So we make a difference now between what should be known by typing in somebodyโs name and what can be known. If you really want to know, then you have to go to the newspaperโs archives.
Keen: KT?
zu Guttenberg: Iโm a bit more critical about the whole thing, again, from the European perspective here, because of raised expectations specifically amongst the public, which are in my opinion unfulfillable.
Swinehart: Yes, exactly.
zu Guttenberg: And of course there was compliance by Google to a certain extent. There were tens of thousands of cases they have to work on at the moment. I think this is quite a challenge to do that. And in the end you may gain a right of being partially forgotten maybe, butโif at all. And I think itโs a pity that this very phrase actually turned out to be the catchphrase for the whole thing then, because itโsโI think weโre far away from what actually would be expected from those looking at it a bit more deeply.
Van Nassau-Oranje: Yeah, I agree. I think this conversation is really important, because weโre actually in the process of adopting regulation where this is much more seriously ingrained. And I think weโthis conversation tells us itโs not as simple as we thought it would be. It is technically impossible. Youโre raising expectations. The second thing is that it is who is arbitrating this? Normally the courts would arbitrate things like this and to have Google arbitrate between what can be forgotten and what shouldnโt be, or arbitrate between what is freedom of speech and what not, I think is a very interesting point to discuss.
Keen: Kara?
Sprague: Yes, Kara Sprague from McKinsey. Weโve been talking a lot about privacy and individual freedoms on the Internet, but I wonder if we could talk a little bit about the other side of it, which is there is a reason why the NSA is so interested in being able to look into various packets and understand what people are doing online. We just came from a discussion where weโre talking about the next biggest threat to the world and even the United States would be a cyberattack. So how do we balance the two, between individual privacy and freedom versus actually protecting a large global infrastructure thatโs increasingly based on the Internet?
Gellman: Well, for one thing, you would want to have that debate to some extent in the open, so that all stakeholders can express views and describe costs and benefits of a proposed course of action. And we have not had that until very recently. And the intelligence community, as intelligence communities do, has done its best to stuff that back under the rug. So there are big initiatives that the NSA would like to take in terms of being able to deep packet inspection in order to protect against cyberattacks, which would have the additional impact of allowing it to filter all traffic that enters or exits the United States, which, you know, has its disadvantages as well. And I will say, there is a certain hypocrisy in the cyber threat-cybersecurity conversation. Itโs got to at some point include and acknowledge the fact that I think it would be fairly hard to dispute that the worldโs most proficient offensive cyber operation is run at the NSA. The big distinction that they make is that they donโt steal other countryโs economic secrets to give private U.S. companies a market advantage. I believe that to be true. But youโre not going to expect every country in the world to play by rules in which the NSA implicitly is saying youโre allowed to steal any secrets you want as long as they donโt come from the area in which weโre already dominant, which is economic innovation. I mean, thatโs not a rule thatโs going to be universally accepted.
Keen: This gentleman.
Hargreaves: Jonathan Hargreaves, European managing director at Edelman. Iโve got a comment on this challenge of the global privacy issue. And Iโm going to refer to a joke told me by a German colleague. They refer to the German privacy paradox, and thatโs that you get a riot if youโre on the Google Map on the street, but Germanโs really enjoy being in a sauna naked, and that this paradox is something that they actually quite enjoy. And to put that forward [โฆ] As always, thereโs a serious point to a German joke.
[LAUGHTER]
And the issue being this, that cultural relevancy plays a massive role in the way that you actually tolerate different interactions with your privacy rights. And as you become more and more aware of the impact from these digital technologies, opinions are changing and moving backwards, moving forwards very fast, and we see this in the tracking data. And actually, I think, in terms of the industry, one of the important things would be to find some form of trying to manage and deal with this fast-evolving issue, rather than simply just seeing it as a form of outrage or something that you comply with without being aware of it.
Keen: But isnโt that the problem, that we live in an age ofโthe media that weโve built around us is designed as an engine of that outrage, butโso we all can get very, very angry about stuff, but we never come up with any solutions to any of it.
zu Guttenberg: I think the political landscape and spectrum is just way too slow for it. And that wonโt change for a while.
Keen: For a while? Will it ever change?
zu Guttenberg: It will probably never change, but the discrepancy is even higher than it used to be, and so that really brings us to your question, do we probably face a restructuring even of the political system in this regard. And thatโs a wider question but itโs one we should actually address.
Keen: Well thatโs one we can spend another hour talking about.
Hargreaves: Well, just as a final point on that, thatโs really what [โฆ]
Keen: David, you havenโt said anything for a while.
Gorodyansky: Yes, I wanted to come back for a second to the point about consumers being asleep and needing a wakeup call. And I actually think that consumers are not asleep. Theyโve woken up a while ago. And I think the testament is that at AnchorFree we just surpassed 300 million downloads of our application, Hotspot Shield, and every single day, 200,000 people every single day download our app on their mobile phones and computers. And I think people arenโt waiting for politicians or for policy. I think theyโre just moving forward and finding solutions that will protect them online. And weโve done some surveys, weโve asked our users, whatโs more important to you? We do three things for you, we protect your privacy, we provide you with uncensored access to information, and we secure everything you do online. Which of those three things, security, privacy, access, are more important? And most of our users do know the difference. They do distinguish those three things into three different buckets. It wasnโt freedom, security, and privacy, it was like, โI want secure and private access to everything I do online. Thatโs why Iโm using you.โ
And so, you know, I think itโs not only a privacy and a freedom point, itโs also a security point. People want to protect their data from malware, from identity thieves, from governments, from everyone. And I think theyโve woken up and I think theyโre doing it.
Keen: Barton, just a quickโ
Gellman: Well I think thereโs a unified narrative you can out of the German sauna paradox, which isโ
Keen: It was a joke, not a paradoxโ
Gellman: Well but a joke that has a serious point. But the narrative is that people want to decide for themselves who gets to see them naked. Thatโs actually exactly what Scarlett Johansson said in her magazine interview after her account was hacked. Just because youโve posed for a photo doesnโt mean that youโve decided you want to let everyone see it or that you want someone to take it against your will.
zu Guttenberg: David, do you also have, in this survey you have made, do you also haveโitโs a banality, but have you asked people as well whether they do read the privacy laws of the apps they are downloading, sophisticatedly as they do? So whenever I talk to people who can maneuver quite well within the app world, I donโt see a single one, including me, who would actually read the 30 plus pages of how they deal with their privacyโ
Keen: And can you be very brief? Weโve got two more questions, then weโve got to end.
Gorodyansky: Yes, I agree. So people donโt read privacy policies and donโtโI think, I mean the answer is we just have to provideโthe security industry at large has to provide really simple privacy levers, so itโs super simple, you press this button and youโre private, right? Because the people who want to abuse our privacy ask us to click a nice lookingโlikeโ button, and we click it and they collect all of our data. So there has to be something else.
Keen: Two more quick comments and then weโre going to end.
Davidson: The question is, is it possible that weโre not actually outraged enoughโIโm sorry, Iโm Alan Davidson with the Open Technology Institute in Washingtonโthat weโre not outraged enough about the fact that certain basic values that weโve taken for granted online might be in peril? So, you know, we take it for granted that the Internetโs a force for free expression and itโs for access to knowledge, for individual empowerment and , but actually, at the same time, weโve got major services blocked, you canโt get Twitter or YouTube, not just in China and Iran but places like Turkey occasionally.
Keen: Youโre not Turkish, why would you be outraged about that?
Davidson: Well I think if you care about those services beingโif you care about access to knowledgeโ
Keen: What if youโre Twitter, though?
Davidson: Well, I think we all should care about it. And that gets to this point, which is that developing the technology may not be enough. I think the greatest reaction to Snowden is that people are actually trying to secure and get access, but we actually have to also choose as to make an informed choice.
Keen: I think thereโs going to be a lot of outrage to get outraged about Twitter in Turkey. Final question, final comment? And then weโre going to get our final, final comments from theโ
Audience: I think where we have a gap right now is weโve got a big disconnect between what has happened technologically and where the regulatory system is at. And weโre missing a framework, so if you look at the framework that is starting to see finally some emergence, itโs around the fact that personal information is an asset. And there are three key sort ofโthere are three forces vying to get access to the asset. The government is trying to tax it, corporations are trying toโessentially trying to buy and sell it, trade in it. And then shady characters trying to steal it. But thereโs no asset model, thereโs no ownership model. So anybody who can get ahold of it essentially can useโ
Keen: Where are we going to get that framework? Left to right again. KT, please.
zu Guttenberg: Will we ever, or where?
Keen: Where. Youโve got to be positive. Weโre in America.
zu Guttenberg: Not around unfortunatelyโ
Keen: Optimistic, where is that framework going to start? Where are we going to get it from? Because I think that was a great final comment.
zu Guttenberg: I think at the place where the outrage is probably the highest. And I do see a certain opportunity in Europe. I do.
Keen: So the outrage is more in Europe than in the U.S.?
zu Guttenberg: Oh, it is.
Keen: Constantijn, youโre in Europe. Is this where the frameworkโs going to come from? Because as everybody said, you had an idea, the right to be forgotten, which has been a disaster. You said it wasnโt implementable.
Van Oranje-Nassau: Well it is implemented, so, but I donโt thinkโ
Keen: But itโs not practical. So whereโs the framework going to come from? Is it going to come from Europe, from Neelie Kroes?
Van Oranje- Nassau: No, not from her. Sheโs left. Maybe thatโs a better position to start a framework.
I think it is a topic where the U.S. and Europe could really unite on, because there are some very significant barriers to overcome. So itโs significant work, but thereโs also a very big common interest to show some leadership in this going forward. So I would hope that we can deal with that in our negotiations.
Keen: Theresa, a framework, whereโs it going to come from?
Swinehart: I think it has to come at the global level. With all due respect to the U.S. and European dialogues that are happening, I really think the conversation has to happen at the global level. It has to bring together the leadership in governments, the private sector, civil society, and look at certain issues in a transparent way and find solutions.
Keen: And thatโs doable?
Swinehart: I think thereโs dialogues happening right now. You haveโ
Keen: Give me an example.
Swinehart: You have the Internet Governance Forum dialogues, you have ICANN meetings, you have the Net Mundial discussions that are happening, you have dialogs such as these that are bringing people together from around the world and looking at certain issues. I think these are the opportunities that we need to use amongst all the different forums to look at policy issues.
Keen: Barton, framework, where is it coming from?
Gellman: I think itโs lots of layers. Thereโs naming and shaming, because there are social norms, absolutely, there are social norms. I mean, so Iโmy business is transparency. My business is putting facts on the table so that people can act on them in a regulatory framework, in a legislative framework, enabling them to bring lawsuits that were thrown out for lack of standing until facts changed that. The day that I wrote one of the stories about what the NSA was doing, cracking into the Google cloud and the Yahoo cloud, that day Yahoo announced that after four years of resisting it, it was going to encrypt its links to users.
Keen: But thatโs not a framework. Thatโs just oneโ
Gellman: My framework is to let the normal mechanisms of accountability, which are varied from social to political to legal, operate. The more you know, the more they operate.
Keen: David, wrap it up. Tell us where weโre going to get our framework from. And not your technology, because thatโs too obvious.
[LAUGHTER]
Gorodyansky: I want to point out that thereโs two and a half billion smartphone users in the world today. Thereโs five billion feature phone users. Those feature phone users are going to come to smartphones soon, and none of them are going to be in the U.S. They are all coming from emerging markets. The next billion people, the next five billion people that are going to come onto the Internet are coming online from India, from Africa, from China, from Brazil. And it would be foolish not to include those countries in dialogue. The framework has to be global I agree with Theresa.
Keen: So with that global framework note, I want to thankโthis was a hard one, but I think we kept you all awake anyway. Thank you very much.
Participants
Constantijn Van Oranje-Nassau
Head of Cabinet, Cabinet of Vice-President Neelie Kroes, European Commission
Theresa Swinehart
Senior Advisor to the President on Global Strategy, Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)