Home Field Advantage Foreign investors may find that their success to date has begun
to spoil some of the prospects in the region. They have attracted the attention
of domestic companies owned by industry giants with the financial and political
clout to compete with foreign investors for attractive properties. These are not
media companies per se–at least not yet. Some are more akin to future
competitors of News Corp., being incubated by industrial conglomerates that want
a way to reach consumers in the growing retail goods markets. Others, especially
in Russia, seem to be diversification plays for the energy sector, dominated by
Gazprom-Media, a wholly owned subsidiary of the largest gas production company
in the world. Its prize possession is the long-established satellite platform
NTV-Plus, which is expected to launch Russia’s first high-definition channel
this year. The country’s largest private-sector consumer services company,
Sistema, owns a media subsidiary that started one of the first Internet Protocol
Television services in Europe in early 2005.Alongside dramatic changes in the broadcasting infrastructure
have come equally far-reaching ones in viewers’ tastes. When the first national
commercial television stations debuted a decade ago, foreign involvement in
those stations usually guaranteed access to U.S. and Western European content
that appealed to local viewers. Since then, however, viewers have come to value programs that speak to their own cultural sentiments. Locally
produced thematic channels are now the norm in many countries–especially in
Russia (where several are produced by NTV-Plus), Poland, Hungary and Romania–and
span such genres as news, sports, movies, business, entertainment and travel.
The popularity of this programming and the sheer volume of numbers are making
life increasingly difficult for even the best-known foreign channel operators,
even those that broadcast in local languages. Murdoch’s experience in Russia is illustrative, too, of a part
of the world where, even in the new EU member states, regulations and
privatization practices are not always in step with Western Europe’s
transparency and open investment climate. The local press was sometimes aghast at the "dumbed- down" programming, but the viewing public seemed to love what the station had to offer. | Not too long ago, another well-known Western investor, Ronald
Lauder, lost his flagship TV station, regaining control only after years of
struggle. Though he is not in the media business at home, Lauder’s grandparents
came from Hungary and Slovakia, and he has long held an attachment to the
region. He set up a company called Central European Media Enterprises (CME) in
the early 1990s, partnering with a Czech national, former dissident
intellectual-turned-entrepreneur Vladimir Zelezny. TV Nova, the first station
CME established, made its debut in the Czech Republic in February 1994. The
local press was sometimes aghast at the "dumbed-down" programming of American
reruns and sensationalist news, but the viewing public seemed to love what the
country’s first privately owned national station had to offer. TV Nova attained
an audience share of 70 percent within 16 months. This unprecedented success prompted the company to expand to
other regional markets, but it was stopped dead in its tracks in 1999 when
Zelezny, who had a falling out with CME and was fired, seized control of the
station. He turned off the channel’s signal and walked off with the staff and
the broadcasting license, arguing that the permit had been issued to him as a
Czech national and not to CME. His action forced CME to embark on a four-year
legal battle that culminated in an international arbitration panel awarding
Lauder’s firm $353 million in compensation, payable by the Czech government, for
the loss of TV Nova. This kind of dispute between partners is less likely to occur
now. The progress in taming the regulatory environment is visible. For example,
the new EU member states do not share Russia’s barriers to foreign ownership.
Nevertheless, investors must be wary of ventures that could have hidden
shareholders or others secretly in control. Since he received the favorable arbitration decision, Lauder
has been on a buying spree in an apparent effort to reestablish CME’s dominant
position in the region. The company has reacquired a majority interest in Czech
TV Nova for approximately $930 million, along with a Czech franchise of the
reality show Big Brother. Lauder also bought a national commercial station in Croatia (also
called Nova TV) in a cash deal worth $29 million, and a sports channel, Galaxie
Sport, which reaches the Czech Republic and Slovakia, for $5.1 million.
According to Michael N. Garin, the chief executive officer of CME, the company
is now looking to expand to other markets in the region and should be able to
pay more than $1 billion for acquisitions. Given the small size of many of the markets in which CME
operates (TV ad spending in the relatively wealthy Czech Republic was only
around $700 million in 2005, and only 10 percent of that in neighboring
Slovakia), this investment is not likely to bring significant returns in the
short-to-medium term. In the future, however, several international media
groups, including News Corp., have seen enough potential in CME to bid on stakes
in the company itself. Lauder confirms that the company is definitely not for
sale. But stay tuned for more media companies to battle in this region, even if
they have to enter through the arena’s back door.
TV Nova in the Czech Republic won a huge audience, but questions
about the license ownership led to a long battle in international courts. Chris Dziadul is the London-based editor of the weekly publication
Broadband TV News Central and East
Europe.
|